Morgan Webb slams Zelda: SS for cartoony graphics, praises UC3 for "Adults&

[QUOTE="madsnakehhh"]

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"]

Who the f*** cares what G4 thinks?

DarkLink77

When they attack Nintendo and praise teh hardcore games, SW apparently.

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"][QUOTE="madsnakehhh"]

When they attack Nintendo and praise teh hardcore games, SW apparently.

nintendoboy16

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"][QUOTE="madsnakehhh"]

When they attack Nintendo and praise teh hardcore games, SW apparently.

nintendoboy16

He has some moments, but yeah, G4 its kind of like the Perez Hilton of video games.

[QUOTE="i5750at4Ghz"]

[QUOTE="charizard1605"] And in spite of that, you fail to see the point. :| Did The Wind Waker teach you nothing? Graphics don't matter jack, it's all about game design and mechanics, and Zelda has that on lock, it's always immaculate. There is literally no other game series that survives ONLY on the basis of pure and sheer level design like Zelda does. Graphics, especially in the case of Zelda, are a means to an end, the end being communicating said game design to the player.charizard1605

So i googled some pics of this irrelevant dudette i've never heard before, and i swear, man, she is ugly as if she's the female version of He-Man.. What ya'll see in her, i have no idea.

[QUOTE="charizard1605"][QUOTE="i5750at4Ghz"] I 100% disagree. Graphics matter just as much as everything else. It's just as much a part of the experience as the gameplay. Humans after all are extremely visual animals.

Pegalamp

G4 its kind of like the Perez Hilton of video games.

madsnakehhh

My hypothesis about Morgan Webb is that she gets bent out of shape whenever a child-friendly games (ie most Nintendo games) get high praise and attention, because she is uncomfortable with the fact that the industry she works in is predominantly targetted towards teenagers and children. Anything acknowledging this fact (for example, Mario or other cartoony characters being the face of the industry) is met with opposition.

So i googled some pics of this irrelevant dudette i've never heard before, and i swear, man, she is ugly as if she's the female version of He-Man.. What ya'll see in her, i have no idea.

Lucianu

She's a woman on a game show, so standards are instantly met. I've always thought she looks like a man with a wig on, kind of like Dana Jacobson from ESPN First Take. Though in her defense, Jacobson is actually worth listening to.

She's a woman on a game show, so standards are instantly met. I've always thought she looks like a man with a wig on, kind of like Dana Jacobson from ESPN First Take.

Renegade_Fury

By the way, now that i remember, make up, clothing, the angle of the shot, all that can make a giant difference. If you get a good photograph, with all the trims and all that, any average Joe can look like the hottest thing ever. I've seen some pics of this female on google.

But that 'Dolph Lundgren' type a face she's got going on cannot be hidden.

But that 'Dolph Lundgren' type a face she's got going on cannot be hidden.

Lucianu

[QUOTE="Renegade_Fury"]

She's a woman on a game show, so standards are instantly met. I've always thought she looks like a man with a wig on, kind of like Dana Jacobson from ESPN First Take.

Lucianu

By the way, now that i remember, make up, clothing, the angle of the shot, all that can make a giant difference. If you get a good photograph, with all the trims and all that, any average Joe can look like the hottest thing ever. I've seen some pics of this female on google.

But that 'Dolph Lundgren' type a face she's got going on cannot be hidden.

LOL, that's so cold, and yet so right! :lol:

She only speaks the truth.DJ_Headshot

morgan webb isnt a ps3 fangirl....shes far from it, i remember she bashed the ps3 for 3 years lol

[QUOTE="madsnakehhh"]

G4 its kind of like the Perez Hilton of video games.

Lto_thaG

:lol: she didn't even slam LoZSS. Not to the point of: "Zelda SUCKS, it's so damn kiddy!!1"

Some of you guys are so touchy when it comes Wii graphics.

I would definitely rather play a new zelda game than a new uncharted game. Which is ironic and depressing because I sold my wii to get a ps3.

[QUOTE="VERTIGO47"]

:lol: she didn't even slam LoZSS. Not to the point of: "Zelda SUCKS, it's so damn kiddy!!1"

Some of you guys are so touchy when it comes Wii graphics.

SRTtoZ

Nintendo or should I say Zelda fanboys are theee most sensitive type. You gotta go easy on em sometimes becauuse they take offense very easily...very passive aggressive everytime I try to have a logical discussion.

:lol: she didn't even slam LoZSS. Not to the point of: "Zelda SUCKS, it's so damn kiddy!!1"

Some of you guys are so touchy when it comes Wii graphics.

VERTIGO47

naw they get touchy when it comes to anything nintendo :roll:

[QUOTE="VERTIGO47"]

:lol: she didn't even slam LoZSS. Not to the point of: "Zelda SUCKS, it's so damn kiddy!!1"

Some of you guys are so touchy when it comes Wii graphics.

eboyishere

naw they get touchy when it comes to anything nintendo :roll:

Just to play the devil's advocate here, this "Morgan Webb says something bad about a nintendo game and something good about a PS3 game!" topic was posted in system wars, so I'd think you should expect people to respond as if morgan webb is attacking one console while supporting the other.

[QUOTE="eboyishere"]

[QUOTE="VERTIGO47"]

:lol: she didn't even slam LoZSS. Not to the point of: "Zelda SUCKS, it's so damn kiddy!!1"

Some of you guys are so touchy when it comes Wii graphics.

xLittlekillx

naw they get touchy when it comes to anything nintendo :roll:

Just to play the devil's advocate here, this "Morgan Webb says something bad about a nintendo game and something good about a PS3 game!" topic was posted in system wars, so I'd think you should expect people to respond as if morgan webb is attacking one console while supporting the other.

True, but if people actually watch the video you will see she backs up her opinion with facts. She doesnt just say "Zelda is bad, la la la la la laaaa" she or I should say THEY explain why they feel the way they do. It makes total sense to some of us...others dont want to see behind the curtain and will choose not to believe it, and thats ok but dont act like she doesnt make a few good points. Believe it or not Adam Sessler is a hardcore gamer so I would choose to take his opinion over the bunch of nobodies on this forum who spout at the mouth without backing anything up.

Adam Sessler is one of the reasons I sold my wii for a ps3. He said Uncharted 2 was the best single player gaming experience he's ever had. I got bored a few hours in and never played it again. And now I can't play the new zelda game. Thank god for the blu ray player and infamous 2.

Adam Sessler is one of the reasons I sold my wii for a ps3. He said Uncharted 2 was the best single player gaming experience he's ever had. I got bored a few hours in and never played it again. And now I can't play the new zelda game. Thank god for the blu ray player and infamous 2.

xLittlekillx

[QUOTE="xLittlekillx"]

[QUOTE="eboyishere"]

naw they get touchy when it comes to anything nintendo :roll:

SRTtoZ

Just to play the devil's advocate here, this "Morgan Webb says something bad about a nintendo game and something good about a PS3 game!" topic was posted in system wars, so I'd think you should expect people to respond as if morgan webb is attacking one console while supporting the other.

True, but if people actually watch the video you will see she backs up her opinion with facts. She doesnt just say "Zelda is bad, la la la la la laaaa" she or I should say THEY explain why they feel the way they do. It makes total sense to some of us...others dont want to see behind the curtain and will choose not to believe it, and thats ok but dont act like she doesnt make a few good points. Believe it or not Adam Sessler is a hardcore gamer so I would choose to take his opinion over the bunch of nobodies on this forum who spout at the mouth without backing anything up.

And yet they called Uncharted 3 innovative...while calling Zelda stale just saying.

And no, Adam Sessler is not a hardcore gamer...

Is Uncharted 2 any better than Uncharted 1? UC1 was mostly a bore-fest for me. ActionRemix

IMO yes. Though I thought UC1 had a bit better story then UC2. But the story in UC2 was also great. Everything else was a massive upgrade.

G4 is full of people like this:

Not real gamers, just fads.

I agree, I would love if nintendo brought there games out of the 90's era nd made them modern like everything else. This is part of the reason I cant stand nintendo anymore, they seem to be riding on past accomplishments. Wake me up when they become revelant to people over 12 years old.

I agree, I would love if nintendo brought there games out of the 90's era nd made them modern like everything else. This is part of the reason I cant stand nintendo anymore, they seem to be riding on past accomplishments. Wake me up when they become revelant to people over 12 years old.

Advid-Gamer

Hey dude, wake up, its about time :)

Coulorfull graphics are for the kiddies is a pretty childish attitude.Marka1700

I agree, I would love if nintendo brought there games out of the 90's era nd made them modern like everything else. This is part of the reason I cant stand nintendo anymore, they seem to be riding on past accomplishments. Wake me up when they become revelant to people over 12 years old.

Advid-Gamer

[QUOTE="Marka1700"]Coulorfull graphics are for the kiddies is a pretty childish attitude.Advid-Gamer

EDIT: Nevermind, Too late:

Critics who treat adult as a term of approval, instead of as a merely descriptive term, cannot be adult themselves. To be concerned about being grown up, to admire the grown up because it is grown up, to blush at the suspicion of being childish; these things are the marks of childhood and adolescence. And in childhood and adolescence they are, in moderation, healthy symptoms. Young things ought to want to grow. But to carry on into middle life or even into early manhood this concern about being adult is a mark of really arrested development. When I was ten, I read fairy tales in secret and would have been ashamed if I had been found doing so. Now that I am fifty I read them openly. When I became a man I put away childish things, including the fear of childishness and the desire to be very grown up. " CS Lewis

Is Uncharted 2 any better than Uncharted 1? UC1 was mostly a bore-fest for me. ActionRemix

I agree, I would love if nintendo brought there games out of the 90's era nd made them modern like everything else. This is part of the reason I cant stand nintendo anymore, they seem to be riding on past accomplishments. Wake me up when they become revelant to people over 12 years old.

Advid-Gamer

[QUOTE="xLittlekillx"]

[QUOTE="eboyishere"]

naw they get touchy when it comes to anything nintendo :roll:

SRTtoZ

Just to play the devil's advocate here, this "Morgan Webb says something bad about a nintendo game and something good about a PS3 game!" topic was posted in system wars, so I'd think you should expect people to respond as if morgan webb is attacking one console while supporting the other.

True, but if people actually watch the video you will see she backs up her opinion with facts. She doesnt just say "Zelda is bad, la la la la la laaaa" she or I should say THEY explain why they feel the way they do. It makes total sense to some of us...others dont want to see behind the curtain and will choose not to believe it, and thats ok but dont act like she doesnt make a few good points. Believe it or not Adam Sessler is a hardcore gamer so I would choose to take his opinion over the bunch of nobodies on this forum who spout at the mouth without backing anything up.

sessler definitely is a HC gamer

Who?

Who?

PhazonBlazer

A Nobody.

Who?

PhazonBlazer

Co host of X-Play.

At least she didnt praise COD in comparison to zelda becauses its for adults, she is still completely wrong though my 25 year old brother hates M games the last game he played was uncharted though but he is still cant wait for LOZSS and cant wait for a day where people stop stereotyping what age group a game is for just because im 20 doesnt mean I hate zelda and love UC I actually love both :)

At least she didnt praise COD in comparison to zelda becauses its for adults, she is still completely wrong though my 25 year old brother hates M games the last game he played was uncharted though but he is still cant wait for LOZSS and cant wait for a day where people stop stereotyping what age group a game is for just because im 20 doesnt mean I hate zelda and love UC I actually love both :)

layton2012

Sounds like she's ashamed to be associated with the stereotype that games are for kids, so she wants to distance herself from games that can be enjoyed by kids.

Wow 15 pages just because someone said a nintendo game looks cartnoony? so what? it does look cartoony why so mad? i dont get it :P. so defensive wow

Wow 15 pages just because someone said a nintendo game looks cartnoony? so what? it does look cartoony why so mad? i dont get it :P. so defensive wow

finalstar2007

Wow 15 pages just because someone said a nintendo game looks cartnoony? so what? it does look cartoony why so mad? i dont get it :P. so defensive wow

finalstar2007

Wow 15 pages just because someone said a nintendo game looks cartnoony? so what? it does look cartoony why so mad? i dont get it :P. so defensive wow

finalstar2007

[QUOTE="finalstar2007"]

Wow 15 pages just because someone said a nintendo game looks cartnoony? so what? it does look cartoony why so mad? i dont get it :P. so defensive wow

TrapJak