Dang this thread got people wound up lol. But yes most of the things are nitpicky, I'll agree. But its the whole package of nitpicks that just make us feel that the 360 is a step back hardware wise and feature wise.
Just put it this way, when my wife first seen me playing Gears with the 360 and I had on the headset, she laughed and said what the hell is that? Ok so say what you want but when my wife even notices something like that, which she isn't tech savy at all, says a whole alot. And for people saying wired headsets of the 360 is better? Isn't the wired headset plugged into the wireless controller? Just saying.
And yes I think most knows that the new 360's come with a hdmi port, but the 20gb premium I would have had to buy the hdmi cable assembly from ms to be able to use hdmi and optical audio. Fact. I'll post a link to circuity city siting that the premium only comes with componant/av cable assembly if yall would like again.
And yes the power brick is a nitpick but do yall realise how much a/v equipment I have and all the cords back there anyway, much less to find a open area where that thing can rest, while the ps3 I was able to just plug it into the closes open plug in the protector.
And then the hdmi/componant cable discussion, yes there is a slight improvement with hdmi, I'm only running my cable what maybe 3 ft so I don't need a 100ft cable run. And also sources such as dvd players, sat. boxes and cable boxes do something better than others. My cable hd box actually looks just as good with componant cables then hdmi, so I use componant. But my Dish box looks better with hdmi, aswell as my hddvd player. So yes you can see a difference and for me it is with the colors, brightness settings for dark levels, and a bit more sharpness. So there is a difference. So don't just say why don't you just use componant, cause I would like to see which is better lol. Not going to buy a ms cable for $60 just to see when I have everything right there if the 360 was made correctly. Edited: Also I did have compression arifacts in Bioshock demo when played in the dark areas and in the water, a hdmi cable may have helped this situation. Happens on my dish box if using componant cables aswell.
Also my tv didn't come with a hdmi cable so I didn't even think other wise when the ps3 didn't come with one, nor did my older upconverting dvd player have one, nor did my hddvd player have one.
I can't get over the fact that the optical audio cable isn't built into the motherboard of the 360. Thats where it went south for me from that point for the 360. And possibly if ms wouldn't have added componant cables or hdmi cables for elites maybe that money could have went for a proper motherboard to have been installed into the 360.
XMB on the ps3 is simple and then the themes that can be used and seen, aswell as just using family pics for a background is awesome. My 4 year old can navigate the xmb with out issues, even installing the demos I downloaded earlier, all by himself. I wouldn't turn him loose on the 360, things just seem to hidden and it is just feels clunky sorry. And then everything just felt like there was a pause between every input movement I did to navigate through the dashboard. Almost like all of the EA games menu screens. Where you accidently move twice cause it didn't move the first time you tried. I guess its just not responsive.
And the game I played was Gears, and I want go into this subject to much, some of you already know my feelings on it. But after a boss battle with the boss getting stuck and I couldn't kill him, and another enemy getting stuck later on that kept the level from moving forward until I found him in a corner, was just enough for me.
So if you say its the drive tray and its nitpicking yes, but as a new owner of a 360 and having the ps3 prior and running into all of these things in a course of a week, it was just mind numbing sorry. From the time at unpackaging the 360, to installing, to playing one of the biggest titles, nothing seemed like quality was never even thought about for the 360. Just my opinion. If you have one I hope you enjoy it.
P.S. No exact test but Tiger woods on xbl downloaded at 20min, on the ps3 is downloaded at 38mins. so neither one your going to sit right down and play. So just start your downloads and forget about them until after some gaming time :)
Log in to comment