[QUOTE="MuayThaiFTW"][QUOTE="AlistarHP"]^Uncharted 3 craps all over gears, reviews a lot of the time are just hype, rewards at the end of the year, after the honeymoon period is over will tell you which is the better game. And Uncharted will destroy Gears in all sorts of awards. Kolev_PlusExactly. Not to mention that Uncharted 2 had over 150 GOTY awards. While Gears 1 AND 2 combined won at the most like 5 GOTY awards lol Yeah, agreed, GEARS is overrated crap, :DNice of you to come to your senses for once and start being realistic . Kudos sir
PS3 has the most diverse library with highest quality exclusives
This topic is locked from further discussion.
So why does the Xbox 360 crush the PS3 in software sales AND have more higher rated games?KC_HokieI don't know about sales, I don't listen to Justin Bieber, but the PS3 has WAY more high scoring games, and higher scoring games, and more variety in high scoring games. Check Metacritic that's a fact.
[QUOTE="ActicEdge"][QUOTE="MuayThaiFTW"] Uncharted 3 sold over 3 million on its first day of release world wide. It took Gears 3 weeks to reach that number And not only that but Uncharted 3 scored significantly more 10's and more 9's as well then Gears 3 on MC and GR , out scored Gears on nearly every major publication that mattered, and not to mention scoring higher user review ratings then Gears 3 as well Uncharted 3 smashed Gears 3 in critical and commercial success, but in your fanboy opinion Gears out does every PS3 exclusive? Lol get real lemming Seems like its been pretty much unanimously agreed upon by critics amd gamers alike that Uncharted 3>>>>>>Gears 3. So deal with it 360 fanboy!MuayThaiFTWShipped. It certainly did not sell that day one.Uncharted 3 = 92 on metacritic gears 3 = 91 on metacriticObviously the amount of 10 and 9s and then balanced out by more lower scores too if the averages are so close.You're both fanboys but the fact that you feel you are neutral is perhaps the biggest lol. No, it was proven to be units SOLD. You might want to recheck your "facts" And the thing with MC is that a troll site desperate for hits can significantly drop a games score with a troll review. And that was the case with Uncharted 3 But if you actually take a look at things. Uncharted 3 scored a significant amount of more 10's then Gears, which is why it still out scores Gears over all despite being hit by the obscure troll sites that Gears wasn't hit by. And only 5 web sites total scored Gears 3 higher then Uncharted Where as over 40 something sites had Uncharted 3 > then or = to Gears While over 20 sites had Uncharted straight up >>>> then Gears 3 Its pretty obvious to see that Uncharted>>> Gears especially if you have played both. And its funny how you claim to be this unbiased and nuetral poster when you are clearly not brohttp://www.gameinformer.com/b/news/archive/2011/11/10/uncharted-3-ships-3-8m-copies.aspx Keep trolling buddy, we're not stupid Also Gears franchise > Uncharted Franchise aggregated scores on both metacritic and here on GS
So why does the Xbox 360 crush the PS3 in software sales AND have more higher rated games?KC_HokieHave you got a link for this years total software sales?
[QUOTE="KC_Hokie"]So why does the Xbox 360 crush the PS3 in software sales AND have more higher rated games?MuayThaiFTWLol when games like Perfect Dark Zero, Crackdown, and Halo ODST are considered its "high scoring" games then you know its b.s.You could make that same argument about the Little Big Planet games, the first Ratchet and Clank game, Flower, the Resistance games, etc. etc.
[QUOTE="KC_Hokie"]So why does the Xbox 360 crush the PS3 in software sales AND have more higher rated games?AlistarHPI don't know about sales, I don't listen to Justin Bieber, but the PS3 has WAY more high scoring games, and higher scoring games, and more variety in high scoring games. Check Metacritic that's a fact. Nope. The Xbox 360 has a higher scoring library.
[QUOTE="KC_Hokie"]So why does the Xbox 360 crush the PS3 in software sales AND have more higher rated games?hoosier7Have you got a link for this years total software sales?It's called the TIE Ratio. Look it up. Also, not a single PS3 exclusive sequel sold more than its predecessor in 2011.
[QUOTE="MuayThaiFTW"][QUOTE="KC_Hokie"]So why does the Xbox 360 crush the PS3 in software sales AND have more higher rated games?KC_HokieLol when games like Perfect Dark Zero, Crackdown, and Halo ODST are considered its "high scoring" games then you know its b.s.You could make that same argument about the Little Big Planet games, the first Ratchet and Clank game, Flower, the Resistance games, etc. etc. Wait what? Are you slow? Your comparing award winning critically acclaimed, genre envelope pushing games like LBP with PDZ and ODST? Are you feeling ok?
No, it was proven to be units SOLD. You might want to recheck your "facts" And the thing with MC is that a troll site desperate for hits can significantly drop a games score with a troll review. And that was the case with Uncharted 3 But if you actually take a look at things. Uncharted 3 scored a significant amount of more 10's then Gears, which is why it still out scores Gears over all despite being hit by the obscure troll sites that Gears wasn't hit by. And only 5 web sites total scored Gears 3 higher then Uncharted Where as over 40 something sites had Uncharted 3 > then or = to Gears While over 20 sited had Uncharted straight up >>>> then Gears 3 Its pretty obvious to see that Uncharted>>> Gears especially if you have played both And its funny how you claim to be this unbiased and nuetral poster when all.I've ever seen you do is defend Microsoft like if you have a stake in the company[QUOTE="MuayThaiFTW"][QUOTE="ActicEdge"]Shipped. It certainly did not sell that day one.Uncharted 3 = 92 on metacritic gears 3 = 91 on metacriticObviously the amount of 10 and 9s and then balanced out by more lower scores too if the averages are so close.You're both fanboys but the fact that you feel you are neutral is perhaps the biggest lol.ActicEdge
No Sony specifically said sold to retailers. I think just a smidgen of logic would point towards a series that couldn't even do a million in its first month suddenly doing 3 million first day not being likely.
Fact of the matter is every game is subject to troll sites from metacritic. That's the name of the game, didn't stop tons of games from scoring higher than U3 even this year alone. I also laugh, I don't own a 360, I'll be getting a PS3 by years end and I never ever insinuated I was neutral. I have an obvious Nintedo slant which should be pretty obvious by my sig, display pic and now playing :|
The only thing metacritic has proved is that Gears 3 was received more consistently than U3 but U3 had more people who were either big fans of it or not. Excuses man, lies (about the sales) and excuses about the reviews. Sorry, both great playing great selling games. No need to try and pin 1 as God and the other as trash. You just look silly.
It was units SOLD to customers you 360 fanboy troll lol jeez. Go look up the article for yourself Gears 3 was not hit by the same troll reviews from obscure hack job sites desperate for hits that U3 was hit by And HOW IN THE WORLD does any of what we just went over prove that Gears 3 scored more consistently then Uncharted 3 when in fact: 1.Uncharted 3 scored a significant amount of more 10's then Gears 3. A SIGNIFICANT amount more 2.Scored more 9's as well 3.Out scored Gears 3 on over 20 sites that scored both 4.Was only out scored by Gears by a total of 5 sites that scored both And yet despite being hit by hack sites desperate for hits, STILL out scored Gears as a whole. Minus the 2 or 4 troll reviews Uncharted would be obliterating Gears. I mean are you capable of any type of logic? You have to be kidding yourself to come to the conclusion that you came to[QUOTE="AlistarHP"][QUOTE="KC_Hokie"]So why does the Xbox 360 crush the PS3 in software sales AND have more higher rated games?KC_HokieI don't know about sales, I don't listen to Justin Bieber, but the PS3 has WAY more high scoring games, and higher scoring games, and more variety in high scoring games. Check Metacritic that's a fact. Nope. The Xbox 360 has a higher scoring library. Maybe if you use some fanboy site with some specific guidelines, if you use Metacritic and consider the VAST maority of professional gaming jornalism the PS3 DESTROYS the 360 in high scoring games, highest scoring games, and variety in high scoring games.
[QUOTE="AlistarHP"][QUOTE="KC_Hokie"]You could make that same argument about the Little Big Planet games, the first Ratchet and Clank game, Flower, the Resistance games, etc. etc.KC_HokieWait what? Are you slow? Your comparing award winning critically acclaimed, genre envelope pushing games like LBP with PDZ and ODST? Are you feeling ok? I'm saying it's totally subjective. I don't like the high scoring PS3 games I listed above but they still count as high scoring games. You can't say certain games don't count as high scoring just because you don't like them. That's my point. No, game slike PDZ scored bad in more places then places where they scored AAA, LBP was universally accepted as a AAA high quality piece of gaming. taste has nothing to do with quality. I don't like sim racing, but forza is still quality. That's how it works.
[QUOTE="ActicEdge"][QUOTE="MuayThaiFTW"] No, it was proven to be units SOLD. You might want to recheck your "facts" And the thing with MC is that a troll site desperate for hits can significantly drop a games score with a troll review. And that was the case with Uncharted 3 But if you actually take a look at things. Uncharted 3 scored a significant amount of more 10's then Gears, which is why it still out scores Gears over all despite being hit by the obscure troll sites that Gears wasn't hit by. And only 5 web sites total scored Gears 3 higher then Uncharted Where as over 40 something sites had Uncharted 3 > then or = to Gears While over 20 sited had Uncharted straight up >>>> then Gears 3 Its pretty obvious to see that Uncharted>>> Gears especially if you have played both And its funny how you claim to be this unbiased and nuetral poster when all.I've ever seen you do is defend Microsoft like if you have a stake in the company MuayThaiFTW
No Sony specifically said sold to retailers. I think just a smidgen of logic would point towards a series that couldn't even do a million in its first month suddenly doing 3 million first day not being likely.
Fact of the matter is every game is subject to troll sites from metacritic. That's the name of the game, didn't stop tons of games from scoring higher than U3 even this year alone. I also laugh, I don't own a 360, I'll be getting a PS3 by years end and I never ever insinuated I was neutral. I have an obvious Nintedo slant which should be pretty obvious by my sig, display pic and now playing :|
The only thing metacritic has proved is that Gears 3 was received more consistently than U3 but U3 had more people who were either big fans of it or not. Excuses man, lies (about the sales) and excuses about the reviews. Sorry, both great playing great selling games. No need to try and pin 1 as God and the other as trash. You just look silly.
It was units SOLD the customers you dumb 360 fanboy troll lol jeez. Go look up the article for yourself Gears 3 was not hit by the same trolling from obscure hack job sites that U3 was hit by And HOW IN THE WORLD does it prove that Gears 3 scored more consistently when Uncharted 3 scored a significant amount of more 10's then Gears 3 Scored more 9's as well Out scored Gears 3 on over 20 sites that scored both Was only out scored by Gears on 5 sites that scored both And despite being hit by hack job sites desperate for hits STILL out scored Gears as a whole I mean are you capable of any type of logic? You have to be nuts to come to the conclusion that you came toNo, it was sold to retailers. there are tons of links to verify this as well. Calling me dumb will not change that reality.
As far as troll sites again, that's metacritic, you don't get to disregard sites you don't agree with lol. This isn't a pick 5 here.
I will admit though that its flawed to say gears 3 was more consistently reviewed. The 2 games reviewed similarly would be a better statement.
[QUOTE="AlistarHP"][QUOTE="KC_Hokie"]Nope. The Xbox 360 has a higher scoring library.KC_HokieMaybe if you use some fanboy site with some specific guidelines, if you use Metacritic and consider the VAST maority of professional gaming jornalism the PS3 DESTROYS the 360 in high scoring games, highest scoring games, and variety in high scoring games.No. Have you actually counted to compare?Yes I have. If you look at the high scoring games on metacritic ignore arcade/psn and DLC and count only actuall normal games the PS3 has more games, more exclusives, more high scoring, more variety and higher scoring. It's EXTREMELY easy to check the info.
[QUOTE="KC_Hokie"][QUOTE="AlistarHP"] Maybe if you use some fanboy site with some specific guidelines, if you use Metacritic and consider the VAST maority of professional gaming jornalism the PS3 DESTROYS the 360 in high scoring games, highest scoring games, and variety in high scoring games.AlistarHPNo. Have you actually counted to compare?Yes I have. If you look at the high scoring games on metacritic ignore arcade/psn and DLC and count only actuall normal games the PS3 has more games, more exclusives, more high scoring, more variety and higher scoring. It's EXTREMELY easy to check the info. No.
http://www.metacritic.com/browse/games/score/metascore/all/ps3?sort=desc&view=condensed&page=2
http://www.metacritic.com/browse/games/score/metascore/all/xbox360?sort=desc&view=condensed&page=2
Both are on the 3rd page worth of games. Look at how many more games 80 and above the Xbox 360 has.
It was units SOLD the customers you dumb 360 fanboy troll lol jeez. Go look up the article for yourself Gears 3 was not hit by the same trolling from obscure hack job sites that U3 was hit by And HOW IN THE WORLD does it prove that Gears 3 scored more consistently when Uncharted 3 scored a significant amount of more 10's then Gears 3 Scored more 9's as well Out scored Gears 3 on over 20 sites that scored both Was only out scored by Gears on 5 sites that scored both And despite being hit by hack job sites desperate for hits STILL out scored Gears as a whole I mean are you capable of any type of logic? You have to be nuts to come to the conclusion that you came to[QUOTE="MuayThaiFTW"][QUOTE="ActicEdge"]
No Sony specifically said sold to retailers. I think just a smidgen of logic would point towards a series that couldn't even do a million in its first month suddenly doing 3 million first day not being likely.
Fact of the matter is every game is subject to troll sites from metacritic. That's the name of the game, didn't stop tons of games from scoring higher than U3 even this year alone. I also laugh, I don't own a 360, I'll be getting a PS3 by years end and I never ever insinuated I was neutral. I have an obvious Nintedo slant which should be pretty obvious by my sig, display pic and now playing :|
The only thing metacritic has proved is that Gears 3 was received more consistently than U3 but U3 had more people who were either big fans of it or not. Excuses man, lies (about the sales) and excuses about the reviews. Sorry, both great playing great selling games. No need to try and pin 1 as God and the other as trash. You just look silly.
ActicEdge
No, it was sold to consumers. there are tons of links to verify this as well. Calling me dumb will not change that reality.
As far as troll sites again, that's metacritic, you don't get to disregard sites you don't agree with lol. This isn't a pick 5 here.
I will admit though that its flawed to say gears 3 was more consistently reviewed. The 2 games reviewed similarly would be a better statement.
Again, where is your logic? How in the world were they scored "similarly" When of the 50 or so web sites that reviewed both, over 20 scored Uncharted HIGHER , while only 5 of the 50 or so that reviewed both scored Gears higher. I mean where is your brain at right now lol no offence. Maybe you are just having 1 big brain fart today Also, it was units sold to customers for the 100th time. It was clearly stated to be so in articals. You seem to be having a lot of trouble today in thinking and in reading criticallyYes I have. If you look at the high scoring games on metacritic ignore arcade/psn and DLC and count only actuall normal games the PS3 has more games, more exclusives, more high scoring, more variety and higher scoring. It's EXTREMELY easy to check the info. No.[QUOTE="AlistarHP"][QUOTE="KC_Hokie"]No. Have you actually counted to compare?KC_Hokie
http://www.metacritic.com/browse/games/score/metascore/all/ps3?sort=desc&view=condensed&page=2
http://www.metacritic.com/browse/games/score/metascore/all/xbox360?sort=desc&view=condensed&page=2
Both are on the 3rd page worth of games. Look at how many more games 80 and above the Xbox 360 has.
That list is jam packed with DLC, arcade, indie games, expansions, multiplats etc. If u remove multipalts also on PS3, DLC, arcade, indie games etc, the PS3 DESTROYS the 360. I'm shocked how you could htink otherwise, where have you been for the last 4 years? The only reason the 360 is even in the competition is because of 2005-2007 old outdated games.[QUOTE="KC_Hokie"]No.[QUOTE="AlistarHP"]Yes I have. If you look at the high scoring games on metacritic ignore arcade/psn and DLC and count only actuall normal games the PS3 has more games, more exclusives, more high scoring, more variety and higher scoring. It's EXTREMELY easy to check the info. AlistarHP
http://www.metacritic.com/browse/games/score/metascore/all/ps3?sort=desc&view=condensed&page=2
http://www.metacritic.com/browse/games/score/metascore/all/xbox360?sort=desc&view=condensed&page=2
Both are on the 3rd page worth of games. Look at how many more games 80 and above the Xbox 360 has.
That list is jam packed with DLC, arcade, indie games, expansions, multiplats etc. If u remove multipalts also on PS3, DLC, arcade, indie games etc, the PS3 DESTROYS the 360. I'm shocked how you could htink otherwise, where have you been for the last 4 years? The only reason the 360 is even in the competition is because of 2005-2007 old outdated games. Excuses, excuses, excuses. It uses the same standard for both systems.Like I said when you look at the lists side by side the Xbox 360 has a library of higher rated games.
Yes I have. If you look at the high scoring games on metacritic ignore arcade/psn and DLC and count only actuall normal games the PS3 has more games, more exclusives, more high scoring, more variety and higher scoring. It's EXTREMELY easy to check the info. No.[QUOTE="AlistarHP"][QUOTE="KC_Hokie"]No. Have you actually counted to compare?KC_Hokie
http://www.metacritic.com/browse/games/score/metascore/all/ps3?sort=desc&view=condensed&page=2
http://www.metacritic.com/browse/games/score/metascore/all/xbox360?sort=desc&view=condensed&page=2
Both are on the 3rd page worth of games. Look at how many more games 80 and above the Xbox 360 has.
Exactly. It's been 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, and now 2011, Xbox 360 has BEAT the PS3 for all those years by having a better games library. The fanboys just won't accept it. They try and pick and choose what games "count", they try to use GS/IGN/Metacritic, they try to go by amount of GOTY awards, etc. At the end of the day, all that BS aside, 360 simply has more good games then PS3. 360 won this console gen in overall games, Wii won in sales and exclusives, PS3 won nothing, except best Blu Ray player :P[QUOTE="KC_Hokie"]No.[QUOTE="AlistarHP"]Yes I have. If you look at the high scoring games on metacritic ignore arcade/psn and DLC and count only actuall normal games the PS3 has more games, more exclusives, more high scoring, more variety and higher scoring. It's EXTREMELY easy to check the info. AlistarHP
http://www.metacritic.com/browse/games/score/metascore/all/ps3?sort=desc&view=condensed&page=2
http://www.metacritic.com/browse/games/score/metascore/all/xbox360?sort=desc&view=condensed&page=2
Both are on the 3rd page worth of games. Look at how many more games 80 and above the Xbox 360 has.
That list is jam packed with DLC, arcade, indie games, expansions, multiplats etc. If u remove multipalts also on PS3, DLC, arcade, indie games etc, the PS3 DESTROYS the 360. I'm shocked how you could htink otherwise, where have you been for the last 4 years? The only reason the 360 is even in the competition is because of 2005-2007 old outdated games. EXACTLY! Beautifully put! So much truth and logic in this post But of course lemmings are going to deny deny deny.... whine whine whine... And continue to cry cry cry
[QUOTE="AlistarHP"][QUOTE="KC_Hokie"]You could make that same argument about the Little Big Planet games, the first Ratchet and Clank game, Flower, the Resistance games, etc. etc.KC_HokieWait what? Are you slow? Your comparing award winning critically acclaimed, genre envelope pushing games like LBP with PDZ and ODST? Are you feeling ok? I'm saying it's totally subjective. I don't like the high scoring PS3 games I listed above but they still count as high scoring games. You can't say certain games don't count as high scoring just because you don't like them. That's my point. I wasn't aware that LBP was a genre envelope pushing game? lol
[QUOTE="KC_Hokie"]No.[QUOTE="AlistarHP"]Yes I have. If you look at the high scoring games on metacritic ignore arcade/psn and DLC and count only actuall normal games the PS3 has more games, more exclusives, more high scoring, more variety and higher scoring. It's EXTREMELY easy to check the info. locopatho
http://www.metacritic.com/browse/games/score/metascore/all/ps3?sort=desc&view=condensed&page=2
http://www.metacritic.com/browse/games/score/metascore/all/xbox360?sort=desc&view=condensed&page=2
Both are on the 3rd page worth of games. Look at how many more games 80 and above the Xbox 360 has.
Exactly. It's been 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, and now 2011, Xbox 360 has BEAT the PS3 for all those years by having a better games library. The fanboys just won't accept it. They try and pick and choose what games "count", they try to use GS/IGN/Metacritic, they try to go by amount of GOTY awards, etc. At the end of the day, all that BS aside, 360 simply has more good games then PS3. 360 won this console gen in overall games, Wii won in sales and exclusives, PS3 won nothing, except best Blu Ray player :P I agree. The 360 has had the better gaming library for a while, but recently the PS3 has made a huge comeback, and now I would say it's pretty close. I still the the 360 gets the edge. It does for me anyways. I play it about 75% of the time, while my PS3 gets about 25% playtime.[QUOTE="ActicEdge"][QUOTE="MuayThaiFTW"] It was units SOLD the customers you dumb 360 fanboy troll lol jeez. Go look up the article for yourself Gears 3 was not hit by the same trolling from obscure hack job sites that U3 was hit by And HOW IN THE WORLD does it prove that Gears 3 scored more consistently when Uncharted 3 scored a significant amount of more 10's then Gears 3 Scored more 9's as well Out scored Gears 3 on over 20 sites that scored both Was only out scored by Gears on 5 sites that scored both And despite being hit by hack job sites desperate for hits STILL out scored Gears as a whole I mean are you capable of any type of logic? You have to be nuts to come to the conclusion that you came toMuayThaiFTW
No, it was sold to consumers. there are tons of links to verify this as well. Calling me dumb will not change that reality.
As far as troll sites again, that's metacritic, you don't get to disregard sites you don't agree with lol. This isn't a pick 5 here.
I will admit though that its flawed to say gears 3 was more consistently reviewed. The 2 games reviewed similarly would be a better statement.
Again, where is your logic? How in the world were they scored "similarly" When of the 50 or so web sites that reviewed both, over 20 scored Uncharted HIGHER , while only 5 of the 50 or so that reviewed both scored Gears higher. I mean where is your brain at right now lol no offence. Maybe you are just having 1 big brain fart today Also, it was units sold to customers for the 100th time. It was clearly stated to be so in articals. You seem to be having a lot of trouble today in thinking and in reading criticallyThey scored similarly because they averaged a 1 point different. Do you not know what an average is?
It was sold to retailers.
http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2011-11-10-sony-uncharted-3-day-one-global-sales
http://www.shacknews.com/article/71035/uncharted-3-hits-38m-sales-in-one-day
And from a Sony representatives twitter
http://twitter.com/#!/jimreilly/statuses/134724747371094016
You can insult my intelligence all you would like, its not hurting my point.
[QUOTE="KC_Hokie"]No.[QUOTE="AlistarHP"]Yes I have. If you look at the high scoring games on metacritic ignore arcade/psn and DLC and count only actuall normal games the PS3 has more games, more exclusives, more high scoring, more variety and higher scoring. It's EXTREMELY easy to check the info. locopatho
http://www.metacritic.com/browse/games/score/metascore/all/ps3?sort=desc&view=condensed&page=2
http://www.metacritic.com/browse/games/score/metascore/all/xbox360?sort=desc&view=condensed&page=2
Both are on the 3rd page worth of games. Look at how many more games 80 and above the Xbox 360 has.
Exactly. It's been 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, and now 2011, Nope! From 2007 on the PS3 continued to score more higher rated exclusives And from that year on a PS3 exclusive has won more GOTY awards throughout the years then any other over hyped 360 exclusive[QUOTE="locopatho"][QUOTE="KC_Hokie"]No.Exactly. It's been 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, and now 2011, Nope! From 2007 on the PS3 continued to score more higher rated exclusives And from that year on a PS3 exclusive has won more GOTY awards throughout the years then any other over hyped 360 exclusive Who really cares about 'exclusives'. It's the collective library of games that matters. And the Xbox 360 has the PS3 beat there.http://www.metacritic.com/browse/games/score/metascore/all/ps3?sort=desc&view=condensed&page=2
http://www.metacritic.com/browse/games/score/metascore/all/xbox360?sort=desc&view=condensed&page=2
Both are on the 3rd page worth of games. Look at how many more games 80 and above the Xbox 360 has.
MuayThaiFTW
Again, where is your logic? How in the world were they scored "similarly" When of the 50 or so web sites that reviewed both, over 20 scored Uncharted HIGHER , while only 5 of the 50 or so that reviewed both scored Gears higher. I mean where is your brain at right now lol no offence. Maybe you are just having 1 big brain fart today Also, it was units sold to customers for the 100th time. It was clearly stated to be so in articals. You seem to be having a lot of trouble today in thinking and in reading critically[QUOTE="MuayThaiFTW"][QUOTE="ActicEdge"]
No, it was sold to consumers. there are tons of links to verify this as well. Calling me dumb will not change that reality.
As far as troll sites again, that's metacritic, you don't get to disregard sites you don't agree with lol. This isn't a pick 5 here.
I will admit though that its flawed to say gears 3 was more consistently reviewed. The 2 games reviewed similarly would be a better statement.
ActicEdge
They scored similarly because they averaged a 1 point different. Do you not know what an average is?
It was sold to retailers.
http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2011-11-10-sony-uncharted-3-day-one-global-sales
http://www.shacknews.com/article/71035/uncharted-3-hits-38m-sales-in-one-day
And from a Sony representatives twitter
http://twitter.com/#!/jimreilly/statuses/134724747371094016
You can insult my intelligence all you would like, its not hurting my point.
Are you completely just ignoring the main point? lol Uncharted 3 scored a significant amount of more 10's And i will try and find the graph and post it for you But over 20 of the 50 something sites that reviewed both scores Uncharted higher Where as only 5 of the 50+ sites scored Gears higher. Also, the IGN artical said that it was actually units sold and not units shipped to retailers. I'll find the artical right now[QUOTE="locopatho"][QUOTE="KC_Hokie"]No.Exactly. It's been 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, and now 2011, Nope! From 2007 on the PS3 continued to score more higher rated exclusives And from that year on a PS3 exclusive has won more GOTY awards throughout the years then any other over hyped 360 exclusive And back to exclusives, GOTY awards, time scales, etc. Anything to ignore the fact that 360 has a bigger and higher scoring libary then PS3 for the past 7 years. Well at least you beat the Wii right ;)http://www.metacritic.com/browse/games/score/metascore/all/ps3?sort=desc&view=condensed&page=2
http://www.metacritic.com/browse/games/score/metascore/all/xbox360?sort=desc&view=condensed&page=2
Both are on the 3rd page worth of games. Look at how many more games 80 and above the Xbox 360 has.
MuayThaiFTW
[QUOTE="ActicEdge"][QUOTE="MuayThaiFTW"] Again, where is your logic? How in the world were they scored "similarly" When of the 50 or so web sites that reviewed both, over 20 scored Uncharted HIGHER , while only 5 of the 50 or so that reviewed both scored Gears higher. I mean where is your brain at right now lol no offence. Maybe you are just having 1 big brain fart today Also, it was units sold to customers for the 100th time. It was clearly stated to be so in articals. You seem to be having a lot of trouble today in thinking and in reading critically MuayThaiFTW
They scored similarly because they averaged a 1 point different. Do you not know what an average is?
It was sold to retailers.
http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2011-11-10-sony-uncharted-3-day-one-global-sales
http://www.shacknews.com/article/71035/uncharted-3-hits-38m-sales-in-one-day
And from a Sony representatives twitter
http://twitter.com/#!/jimreilly/statuses/134724747371094016
You can insult my intelligence all you would like, its not hurting my point.
Are you completely just ignoring the main point? lol Uncharted 3 scored a significant amount of more 10's And i will try and find the graph and post it for you But over 20 of the 50 something sites that reviewed both scores Uncharted higher Where as only 5 of the 50+ sites scored Gears higher. Also, the IGN artical said that it was actually units sold and not units shipped to retailers. I'll find the artical right nowWhat main point? I care about the actual metacritic score. I don't care about what sites thought U3>GeoW3, its irrelevant to the point that they ended up with similar scores indicating similar levels of quality. By picking and choosing you are manipulating the scoring system to make a point which by and large isn't the reality. If the general concensus was U3 was so much better than Gears 3 the scores would reflect that and they simply don't.
The IGN artical is not the most recent news. The twitter post where the SCEA representative says it was shipped is. Don't waste your time finding the link.
Nope! From 2007 on the PS3 continued to score more higher rated exclusives And from that year on a PS3 exclusive has won more GOTY awards throughout the years then any other over hyped 360 exclusive Who really cares about 'exclusives'. It's the collective library of games that matters. And the Xbox 360 has the PS3 beat there. Both systems have a good enough library. But just Lol, Because a lot of the games that get counted towards the 360's "collective library" and were counted by stevo the gamer in that big 360 has more games and higher scoring games fanboy thread....are and were old ps2 ports and old 2005 and 2006 versions of sports games that never came out for the PS3, because it wasn't released yet. A lot of gamers didnt care back then nor do they still care about those games now and It is those games which pad the 360's stats significantly. And a lot of it being xbl titles as well Its also important to note that a lot of the 360's early exclusives had their sequels come out on the PS3 or had the orginals released at a later time for the PS3[QUOTE="MuayThaiFTW"][QUOTE="locopatho"] Exactly. It's been 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, and now 2011,KC_Hokie
Are you completely just ignoring the main point? lol Uncharted 3 scored a significant amount of more 10's And i will try and find the graph and post it for you But over 20 of the 50 something sites that reviewed both scores Uncharted higher Where as only 5 of the 50+ sites scored Gears higher. Also, the IGN artical said that it was actually units sold and not units shipped to retailers. I'll find the artical right now[QUOTE="MuayThaiFTW"][QUOTE="ActicEdge"]
They scored similarly because they averaged a 1 point different. Do you not know what an average is?
It was sold to retailers.
http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2011-11-10-sony-uncharted-3-day-one-global-sales
http://www.shacknews.com/article/71035/uncharted-3-hits-38m-sales-in-one-day
And from a Sony representatives twitter
http://twitter.com/#!/jimreilly/statuses/134724747371094016
You can insult my intelligence all you would like, its not hurting my point.
ActicEdge
What main point? I care about the actual metacritic score. I don't care about what sites thought U3>GeoW3, its irrelevant to the point that they ended up with similar scores indicating similar levels of quality. By picking and choosing you are manipulating the scoring system to make a point which by and large isn't the reality. If the general concensus was U3 was so much better than Gears 3 the scores would reflect that and they simply don't.
The IGN artical is not the most recent news. The twitter post where the SCEA representative says it was shipped is. Don't waste your time finding the link.
My god are you dense! Uncharted scored significantly more 10's then Gears 3 did And scored more 9's as well And out scored Gears on nearly every publication that mattered. And when we dig deeper into the number we see that more sites that reviewed both scored Uncharted higher then scored Gears higher. And that also says something. However a "manipulation" of the scoring system did in fact occur when some small obscure troll sites desperate for hits troll reviewed Uncharted 3. I mean when you see Uncharted scoring 10's and then you see a 4 sandwhiched in between a hundred 10's, are you really going to take that review serious? Let's be real here bro. Use your head please. And despite several troll sites(probably xbots in disguise)dropping Uncharted's average score considerable it STILL managed to out scored Gears on a total average. That says it all
The Wii and 360 both have stellar line ups that more than warrant the purchase of each, but yes, the PS3 does have the best line up of games. The PS3 seems to be gaining momentum right now while Xbox and Wii seem to be slowing down and preparing for the next generation.
[QUOTE="ActicEdge"][QUOTE="MuayThaiFTW"] Are you completely just ignoring the main point? lol Uncharted 3 scored a significant amount of more 10's And i will try and find the graph and post it for you But over 20 of the 50 something sites that reviewed both scores Uncharted higher Where as only 5 of the 50+ sites scored Gears higher. Also, the IGN artical said that it was actually units sold and not units shipped to retailers. I'll find the artical right nowMuayThaiFTW
What main point? I care about the actual metacritic score. I don't care about what sites thought U3>GeoW3, its irrelevant to the point that they ended up with similar scores indicating similar levels of quality. By picking and choosing you are manipulating the scoring system to make a point which by and large isn't the reality. If the general concensus was U3 was so much better than Gears 3 the scores would reflect that and they simply don't.
The IGN artical is not the most recent news. The twitter post where the SCEA representative says it was shipped is. Don't waste your time finding the link.
My god are you dense! Uncharted scored significantly more 10's then Gears 3 And scored more 9's as well And out scored Gears on nearly eveey publication that mattered. And when we dig deeper into the number we see that more sites that reviewed both scored Uncharted higher then score Gears higher. And that also says something However a "manipulation" of the scoring system did in fact occur when some small obscure troll sites desperate for hits troll reviewed Uncharted 3 I mean when you see Uncharted scoring 10's and then you see a 4 sandwhiched in between a hundred 10's are you really going to take that review serious? Let's be real here bro. Use your head please. And despite several troll sites(probably xbots in disguise)dropping Uncharted's average score considerable it STILL managed to out scored Gears on a total average.Alright, if sooooooo many more sites scored U3 better than Gears 3, why is there a single point difference? I laugh at the whole "sites that matter" and "troll sites". This is metacritic, if its included in the average they thought it mattered enough. The idea that you can say otherwise is laughable. I've already won this debate though so have fun. You can have the last word though, the satisfaction of winning is more than enough :)
My god are you dense! Uncharted scored significantly more 10's then Gears 3 And scored more 9's as well And out scored Gears on nearly eveey publication that mattered. And when we dig deeper into the number we see that more sites that reviewed both scored Uncharted higher then score Gears higher. And that also says something However a "manipulation" of the scoring system did in fact occur when some small obscure troll sites desperate for hits troll reviewed Uncharted 3 I mean when you see Uncharted scoring 10's and then you see a 4 sandwhiched in between a hundred 10's are you really going to take that review serious? Let's be real here bro. Use your head please. And despite several troll sites(probably xbots in disguise)dropping Uncharted's average score considerable it STILL managed to out scored Gears on a total average.[QUOTE="MuayThaiFTW"][QUOTE="ActicEdge"]
What main point? I care about the actual metacritic score. I don't care about what sites thought U3>GeoW3, its irrelevant to the point that they ended up with similar scores indicating similar levels of quality. By picking and choosing you are manipulating the scoring system to make a point which by and large isn't the reality. If the general concensus was U3 was so much better than Gears 3 the scores would reflect that and they simply don't.
The IGN artical is not the most recent news. The twitter post where the SCEA representative says it was shipped is. Don't waste your time finding the link.
ActicEdge
Alright, if sooooooo many more sites scored U3 better than Gears 3, why is there a single point difference? I laugh at the whole "sites that matter" and "troll sites". This is metacritic, if its included in the average they thought it mattered enough. The idea that you can say otherwise is laughable. I've already won this debate though so have fun. You can have the last word though, the satisfaction of winning is more than enough :)
Oh my gosh lol you are something else You do realise that Uncharted 3 was at 94 and stayed there for WEEKS after its release , until just recently, where small obscure troll sites managed to get a hold of the game and troll review it, to get hits to their web site. Its easy to see what is what though I mean when Uncharted 3 is scoring 10's left and right and then all the sudden you see a 4 and a 7 sandwhiched in between all the 10's given from sites you've never heard of , you want us to take those scores seriously while disregarding all the 10's? Lol you clearly are not capable of commen sense if you cant distinguish between a troll review and a troll site vs ones that are not. Bottom line is that Uncharted out scored Gears on more web sites and ones that actually mattered
Bottom line is that Uncharted out scored Gears on more web sites and ones that actually matteredMuayThaiFTW
Translation: Sites that give it the score I want are credible, sites that give it the score I didn't want do not matter and are obviously trolling. :lol:
[QUOTE="MuayThaiFTW"] Bottom line is that Uncharted out scored Gears on more web sites and ones that actually matteredStevo_the_gamer
Translation: Sites that give it the score I want are credible, sites that give it the score I didn't want do not matter and are obviously trolling. :lol:
Basically, I already disected his argument anyway. I won this easily. Stevo can we battle again? I remember when I first joined this site I use to but heads with you all the time. Then you went soft on us :P
The Wii hate mantra died long ago, friend. Probably because I bought one and realized it wasn't a plastic devil in disguise and was actually quite good--RE4 being amazing on the Wii might have helped too.Basically, I already disected his argument anyway. I won this easily. Stevo can we battle again? I remember when I first joined this site I use to but heads with you all the time. Then you went soft on us :P
ActicEdge
[QUOTE="locopatho"][QUOTE="KC_Hokie"]No.noth are on the 3rd page worth of games. Look at how many more games 80 and above the Xbox 360 has.godzillavskongExactly. It's been 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, and now 2011, Xbox 360 has BEAT the PS3 for all those years by having a better games library. The fanboys just won't accept it. They try and pick and choose what games "count", they try to use GS/IGN/Metacritic, they try to go by amount of GOTY awards, etc. At the end of the day, all that BS aside, 360 simply has more good games then PS3. 360 won this console gen in overall games, Wii won in sales and exclusives, PS3 won nothing, except best Blu Ray player :P I agree. The 360 has had the better gaming library for a while, but recently the PS3 has made a huge comeback, anow I would say it's pretty close. I still the the 360 gets the edge. It does for me anyways. I play it about 75% of the time, while my PS3 gets about 25% playtime. That's absolutely false. The PS3 already started "catching up" to the 360 beginning in 2007. Now in 2011 its not even a contest. The PS3 has the better and higher rated exclusives by far And its important to note that old PS2 ports, old 2005 and 2006 versions of sports games from early this gen, that no one cares about PAD the 360's exclusive library significantly As well as XBL titles. And that exclusive titles from early in this gen like Mass Effect and Bio Shock and Lost Planet and Dead Rising ALL either had their sequels released on the PS3 or had their originals re released for the PS3 Yet a lot of those games still are only counted towards the 360's library. Take out all the padding and filler and the PS3 absolutely CRUSHES the 360 in having more exclusives and better exclusives Also, I play my PS3 about 90% of the time, while my 360 gets about 10% playtime from me, so who cares
[QUOTE="MuayThaiFTW"] Bottom line is that Uncharted out scored Gears on more web sites and ones that actually matteredStevo_the_gamer
Translation: Sites that give it the score I want are credible, sites that give it the score I didn't want do not matter and are obviously trolling. :lol:
Are you insane? How do you figure that troll? We can come to that conclusion based on the fact that of the 50 or so review sites that scored both, more sites scored Uncharted higher, then scored Gears higher. And yeah, let's only regard the 4 , sandwhiched in between all the 10's, while disregarding all the 10's. Lol you done trolling now?[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"][QUOTE="MuayThaiFTW"] Bottom line is that Uncharted out scored Gears on more web sites and ones that actually matteredActicEdgeTranslation: Sites that give it the score I want are credible, sites that give it the score I didn't want do not matter and are obviously trolling. :lol:Basically, I already disected his argument anyway. I won this easily. Stevo can we battle again? I remember when I first joined this site I use to but heads with you all the time. Then you went soft on us :P Lol you didn't disect anything. I tore your flimsy argument apart. I wouldn't be too excited that stevo the gamer agreed and came to your defense though...suprise he's a lemming at heart....of course he will....and We've already had our arguments as well
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment