Uncharted 3 vs. Gears 3 - Serious Graphics Analysis

[QUOTE="rasengan2552"]

waltefmoney

[QUOTE="waltefmoney"]

So you're comparing cutscenes with gameplay?rasengan2552

No it wasn't.

Here is the first ingame shot I found of gears 3 by typing the games name into google. I cant honestly believe people are saying this looks on par with the first Gears game, its easily better. As you can see its a proper in game shot showing the actual game being played and not a cut scene. Perhaps it should be a rule for SW that any graphic thread comparing games must only use native res shots based on in game footage.

ccagracing

[QUOTE="waltefmoney"]

[QUOTE="rasengan2552"]

rasengan2552

[QUOTE="ccagracing"]

Here is the first ingame shot I found of gears 3 by typing the games name into google. I cant honestly believe people are saying this looks on par with the first Gears game, its easily better. As you can see its a proper in game shot showing the actual game being played and not a cut scene. Perhaps it should be a rule for SW that any graphic thread comparing games must only use native res shots based on in game footage.

drakekratos

Lol

In that case here is a "in-game" screenshot.... No depth of field in this for you. If you cant admit that Gears 3 looks good easily on a par with any PS3 then your glasses are a special coloured tint of rose!

if there was to be a fight, marcus would slay drake.

and its a shame that epic's talents are being wasted on a console game. they should be on pc.

[QUOTE="rasengan2552"]

[QUOTE="waltefmoney"]

So you're comparing cutscenes with gameplay?waltefmoney

its a melee scene, no bull shot.

Also here is footage of Drake walking in the desert, in-game.

[QUOTE="drakekratos"]

[QUOTE="ccagracing"]

Here is the first ingame shot I found of gears 3 by typing the games name into google. I cant honestly believe people are saying this looks on par with the first Gears game, its easily better. As you can see its a proper in game shot showing the actual game being played and not a cut scene. Perhaps it should be a rule for SW that any graphic thread comparing games must only use native res shots based on in game footage.

ccagracing

Lol

In that case here is a "in-game" screenshot.... No depth of field in this for you. If you cant admit that Gears 3 looks good easily on a par with any PS3 then your glasses are a special coloured tint of rose!

ccagracing

this looks nothing like Gears Of War, bullshot If ive ever seen one.

[QUOTE="ccagracing"]

[QUOTE="drakekratos"] I'm not impressed. The gun looks bad. Not bad ass. Just bad. The enemy looks generic and bland. The light in his belly is not impressive. Back of Fenix head is not detailed at all. Evvironment is blurry and not detailed.

hoosier7

Lol

In that case here is a "in-game" screenshot.... No depth of field in this for you. If you cant admit that Gears 3 looks good easily on a par with any PS3 then your glasses are a special coloured tint of rose!

I agree, notice how i Put "in game" in quotations as that other guy keeps posting cut scenes as in game footage! Both these games look bloody good and only an idiot / fanboy (delete as required) would say different. I personally believe Crysis 2 is still better than both.

I dont know why he's posting bullshots of Gears 3... even the bullshots don't look that good. Gears is more comparable to Vaquish than Uncharted. drakekratos

Post a single in game shot where we can see the Uncharted 3 Hud. No more cut scenes.

honestly, those screens you posted of Gears are more on par with Vanquish than Uncharted 3. dont get me wrong, it still looks good, but Uncharted is a whole other leveldrakekratos

:roll:

You know deep down that the "whole other level" comment is just crazy talk so I don't know why you continue to do this. It's as if you cows need to do it in order to try to brainwash people into your line of thinking knowing damn well that kind of talk is a LIE when it comes to these games. They are very close that it could basically be seen as a toss up.

But again if someone is forcing me to choose right now I have to say Gears 3 because of the downgrade in the UC3 MP graphics. The graphics in Geras 3 looks sick in SP and MP!

[QUOTE="drakekratos"]I dont know why he's posting bullshots of Gears 3... even the bullshots don't look that good. Gears is more comparable to Vaquish than Uncharted. ccagracing

Post a single in game shot where we can see the Uncharted 3 Hud. No more cut scenes.

Lol he won't because it will slowly begin to let the air out of his hype balloon :P

[QUOTE="drakekratos"]I dont know why he's posting bullshots of Gears 3... even the bullshots don't look that good. Gears is more comparable to Vaquish than Uncharted. ccagracing

Post a single in game shot where we can see the Uncharted 3 Hud. No more cut scenes.

[QUOTE="ccagracing"]

[QUOTE="drakekratos"] I'm not impressed. The gun looks bad. Not bad ass. Just bad. The enemy looks generic and bland. The light in his belly is not impressive. Back of Fenix head is not detailed at all. Evvironment is blurry and not detailed.

hoosier7

Lol

In that case here is a "in-game" screenshot.... No depth of field in this for you. If you cant admit that Gears 3 looks good easily on a par with any PS3 then your glasses are a special coloured tint of rose!

I'd tap that

I really never got why people praise the graphics so much in the Uncharted series, don't get me wrong it looks good and they do a good job with the characters. But really outside of the pre-rendered cutscenes it's not exactly mindblowing (partly because everyone hypes the crap out of the graphics and then you actually play it and just leaves you going: 'meh'). TBH there are quite a number of games on par or even *gasp* better than the games in the Uncharted series but somehow the 'argument' always comes back 'no Uncharted looks better!!! How dare you say that you heathen!!! (frowny face)' and it always gets brought up even if the game in question is Crysis modded to hell and back. It's like a really bad running joke that everyone helps to keep running but doesn't realize it's a joke.

This is pathetic, honestly

Any Uncharted pic that comes up, even if it is clearly a bullshot, or even a crappy looking shot, is praised for being the most technically and graphically advanced thing in the universe.

Any Gears pic that comes up, even if it is clearly on par, and especially if it looks in any bit superior, is nitpicked, and regarded as last gen Xbot trash.

I played the beta for Gears 3. It looks untouchably beautiful. Lighting and textures and animation are all up to snuff. Also, character models? Gears 3 isn't going for realistic looking models, they're all juiced up and bulky for EFFECT and ART DESIGN.

huge biceps for win

Also here is footage of Drake walking in the desert, in-game.

rasengan2552

I honestly cannot tell if you are serious...

[QUOTE="rasengan2552"]

Also here is footage of Drake walking in the desert, in-game.

balfe1990

I honestly cannot tell if you are serious...

So the TC has started an "Uncharted 3 vs. Gears 3 - Serious Graphics Analysis" without any actual game footage and the footage being posted is actually compressed Cut Scene footage for the main and a series of his own opinions without any proof to back them up, only in System Wars!! Bottom line is both games look great and if you have both consoles you are in for a treat this year.

I dont know why he's posting bullshots of Gears 3... even the bullshots don't look that good. Gears is more comparable to Vaquish than Uncharted. drakekratos

characters in gears are big so they are not realestic and UC3 wins? your joking right?then gears suck because it has locusts which are not realestic!!!

dude ofcourse gears charachters are big since it's a fantasy and that's what makes gears be a diferent expriece from other shooters.character models in gears are awesome.dude if you want to compair grfix you need to talk about face textures and complexity of the models and faces and how realestic they look in their world not size of the characters.

characters in gears are big so they are not realestic and UC3 wins? your joking right?then gears suck because it has locusts which are not realestic!!!

dude ofcourse gears charachters are big since it's a fantasy and that's what makes gears be a diferent expriece from other shooters.character models in gears are awesome.dude if you want to compair grfix you need to talk about face textures and complexity of the models and faces and how realestic they look in their world not size of the characters.

noob-saibot2010

[QUOTE="noob-saibot2010"]

characters in gears are big so they are not realestic and UC3 wins? your joking right?then gears suck because it has locusts which are not realestic!!!

dude ofcourse gears charachters are big since it's a fantasy and that's what makes gears be a diferent expriece from other shooters.character models in gears are awesome.dude if you want to compair grfix you need to talk about face textures and complexity of the models and faces and how realestic they look in their world not size of the characters.

drakekratos

Don't want to participate in this thread really, but how the hell could you possinly know which game perfroms better?!

They're both months away from release....

I played the Gears beta and it was silky smooth, even on my slow ass connection. Not sure what you were playing...

[QUOTE="drakekratos"][QUOTE="noob-saibot2010"]

characters in gears are big so they are not realestic and UC3 wins? your joking right?then gears suck because it has locusts which are not realestic!!!

dude ofcourse gears charachters are big since it's a fantasy and that's what makes gears be a diferent expriece from other shooters.character models in gears are awesome.dude if you want to compair grfix you need to talk about face textures and complexity of the models and faces and how realestic they look in their world not size of the characters.

balfe1990

Don't want to participate in this thread really, but how the hell could you possinly know which game perfroms better?!

They're both months away from release....

I played the Gears beta and it was silky smooth, even on my slow ass connection. Not sure what you were playing...

characters in gears are big so they are not realestic and UC3 wins? your joking right?then gears suck because it has locusts which are not realestic!!!

dude ofcourse gears charachters are big since it's a fantasy and that's what makes gears be a diferent expriece from other shooters.character models in gears are awesome.dude if you want to compair grfix you need to talk about face textures and complexity of the models and faces and how realestic they look in their world not size of the characters.

noob-saibot2010

[QUOTE="balfe1990"]

[QUOTE="drakekratos"] Read the OP. I brought up many valid points that have yet to be countered. Everything from realism to lighting to frames per second. Uncharted 3 currently has better graphics and performance than Gears 3. MFDOOM1983

Don't want to participate in this thread really, but how the hell could you possinly know which game perfroms better?!

They're both months away from release....

I played the Gears beta and it was silky smooth, even on my slow ass connection. Not sure what you were playing...

But whats the problem with that?

For 90% of people, 30 fps is absolutely fine.

(that other 10% are the spoilt hermits:P)

[QUOTE="MFDOOM1983"][QUOTE="balfe1990"]

Don't want to participate in this thread really, but how the hell could you possinly know which game perfroms better?!

They're both months away from release....

I played the Gears beta and it was silky smooth, even on my slow ass connection. Not sure what you were playing...

balfe1990

But whats the problem with that?

For 90% of people, 30 fps is absolutely fine.

(that other 10% are the spoilt hermits:P)

[QUOTE="balfe1990"]

[QUOTE="MFDOOM1983"] Digital foundry said it runs at 30fps locked with some drops occasionally.MFDOOM1983

But whats the problem with that?

For 90% of people, 30 fps is absolutely fine.

(that other 10% are the spoilt hermits:P)

This is my point exactly. This drakekratos bloke is just posting stuff that has no basis in fact.

Unless he's the lead designer at Naughty Dog or something, I think I'm going to ignore him.

The last thing we need is another TintedEyes, I was enjoying the peace and quiet.

Read the OP. I brought up many valid points that have yet to be countered. Everything from realism to lighting to frames per second. Uncharted 3 currently has better graphics and performance than Gears 3. drakekratos

Your points were countered many pages back, you just ignored it. Here it is again...

[QUOTE="drakekratos"]

I am not bias, I just tell the truth. Honestly, tell me where was I wrong in my analysis. Uncharted 3 is obviously more realistic, better character models, more varied environments, way better animations, etc... Tell me where was I wrong?

ChubbyGuy40

Oh quit the charade we all know you're a raging PS3 fanboy. You're analysis is nothing more than UC3 praising.

Character models - opinion. Yes they look great, but so do Gears's models. Realistic =/= better. Some of us prefer guys with biceps that make Mark McGuire's look like a baby. Some people don't like looking at Lara Croft after a sex change, an accountant, and an old guy with a really bad porn 'stache.

Environments - Opinion. Why do I want oversaturation in a mature game like Uncharted? Might as well be playing Mario. I need manly grey and brown in my mature games.

Special Effects - Also opinion. I'm already pretty much set on Gears 3 because the MP was amazing graphically.

Lighting - Pretty sure UE3 has more advanced lighting in use than Uncharted. Until we get some tech junkies who've looked at the tech behind each we can't have a fact.

Colors - Opinion. Gears is grey and brown with some yellow, Uncharted looks like it came out of a Hasbro factory.

Realism - I don't remember RL having so much damn blur added to everything. I also don't remember having a blur filter be put on someone while they are simply walking. Any realism stride in Uncharted is held back by some kind of blur because it looks ugly in reality. Its not a fair comparison either because Gears is sci-fi.

Frame Rate - Uncharted 2 had frame-rate drops a lot. I was lied to before I played it. When you actually go through that train crash a second time (when you are rescued) there were a lot during the battles. Same with the jungle near the beginning and the end. Gears 3 MP was silky smooth. Not 60FPS smooth but neither is Uncharted.

Animation - I'll admit Drake's animations are really nice, but I don't think someone can swing from one brick to another 10 feet away. Gears is Gears. Nothing bad and nothing extordinary.

Destruction - Scripted, non-dynamic destruction vs no destruction at all. The only category where Uncharted would actually win regardless.

Conclusion - Someone mad.

[QUOTE="drakekratos"][QUOTE="noob-saibot2010"]

characters in gears are big so they are not realestic and UC3 wins? your joking right?then gears suck because it has locusts which are not realestic!!!

dude ofcourse gears charachters are big since it's a fantasy and that's what makes gears be a diferent expriece from other shooters.character models in gears are awesome.dude if you want to compair grfix you need to talk about face textures and complexity of the models and faces and how realestic they look in their world not size of the characters.

balfe1990

Don't want to participate in this thread really, but how the hell could you possinly know which game perfroms better?!

They're both months away from release....

I played the Gears beta and it was silky smooth, even on my slow ass connection. Not sure what you were playing...

[QUOTE="balfe1990"]

[QUOTE="drakekratos"] Read the OP. I brought up many valid points that have yet to be countered. Everything from realism to lighting to frames per second. Uncharted 3 currently has better graphics and performance than Gears 3. drakekratos

Don't want to participate in this thread really, but how the hell could you possinly know which game perfroms better?!

They're both months away from release....

I played the Gears beta and it was silky smooth, even on my slow ass connection. Not sure what you were playing...

you again withe the U3 threads?? I wasn't all that impressed with it to be honest. Most of what you show for comparisons anyway is CGI. Sure its in game like they were in U2 but they are touched up compared to gameplya because they are mo cap scenes. This was evident in U2 also

you again withe the U3 threads?? I wasn't all that impressed with it to be honest. Most of what you show for comparisons anyway is CGI. Sure its in game like they were in U2 but they are touched up compared to gameplya because they are mo cap scenes. This was evident in U2 also

seanmcloughlin

[QUOTE="waltefmoney"]

[QUOTE="rasengan2552"] thats not a cutscene, that was in-game footage.rasengan2552

its a melee scene, no bull shot.

Also here is footage of Drake walking in the desert, in-game.

[QUOTE="bryn8150"]

and yet Gears 3 will absolutely CURB STOMP Uncharted 3 in sales......

funny.

rasengan2552

[QUOTE="rasengan2552"][QUOTE="bryn8150"]

and yet Gears 3 will absolutely CURB STOMP Uncharted 3 in sales......

funny.

mitu123

[QUOTE="mitu123"][QUOTE="rasengan2552"] just like MW3 will sell more than BF3 ...go figure ... sales =/= qualityjohny300

I don't know how people find it boring :) the pacing is fantastic in it. Better than everything turned up to 11 all the time

battlefield 3 is going to OWN uncharted 3.......pass it on

[QUOTE="mitu123"][QUOTE="rasengan2552"] just like MW3 will sell more than BF3 ...go figure ... sales =/= qualityjohny300

[QUOTE="johny300"][QUOTE="mitu123"] I finally agree with you on something.=p BF3 is going to wreck MW3, and UC3 in graphics.mitu123