Uncharted 3 vs. Gears 3 - Serious Graphics Analysis

[QUOTE="soulitane"][QUOTE="drakekratos"]Why are you posting PC shots? ChubbyGuy40

And he entirely misunderstood what I said and went on a serious rampage for no reason.

I don't see why people compare these 2 games. The ony thing similiar between the two is the cover system, and that's not even close.

el3m2tigre

You probably think there is "nothing special" about this Gif either, despite the fact it looks like CGI even though it's real time.

drakekratos

i bet it's only 1 button gameplay though :D

[QUOTE="waltefmoney"]

[QUOTE="rasengan2552"] thats not a cutscene, that was in-game footage.rasengan2552

its a melee scene, no bull shot.

Also here is footage of Drake walking in the desert, in-game.

gameplay there must be real fun

Who would of thought an unfinished game isnt up there with the best graphics. lol Seriously guys the same conversation was had back with gears 2 and uncharted 2 and when it was all said and done uncharted trumped every game on consoles in graphics and the same will happen this time around also. When more screenshots start coming out of Uncharted 3 people will say those are bullshots again just like they said with uncharted 2 and it turned out to be actual gameplay people need to quit underestimating naughty dog they are gods when it comes to pushing a consoles hardware they havent let us down with ether uncharted games and they wont start anytime soon.

[QUOTE="drakekratos"]

You probably think there is "nothing special" about this Gif either, despite the fact it looks like CGI even though it's real time.

butisitbluray

i bet it's only 1 button gameplay though :D

Nice opinion. Now where's the analysis?

[QUOTE="butisitbluray"]

[QUOTE="drakekratos"]

You probably think there is "nothing special" about this Gif either, despite the fact it looks like CGI even though it's real time.

Ninja_Odin

i bet it's only 1 button gameplay though :D

really..there is NO replayability..once you seen it once its done

its like Dragon's Lair

[QUOTE="Ninja_Odin"]

[QUOTE="butisitbluray"]

i bet it's only 1 button gameplay though :D

butisitbluray

really..there is NO replayability..once you seen it once its done

its like Dragon's Lair

haters gon' hate i suppose.

haters gon' hate i suppose.

rumbalumba

[QUOTE="drakekratos"]

You probably think there is "nothing special" about this Gif either, despite the fact it looks like CGI even though it's real time.

butisitbluray

i bet it's only 1 button gameplay though :D

Do you expect 10 button gameplay?

[QUOTE="butisitbluray"]

[QUOTE="drakekratos"]

You probably think there is "nothing special" about this Gif either, despite the fact it looks like CGI even though it's real time.

mrmusicman247

i bet it's only 1 button gameplay though :D

Do you expect 10 button gameplay?

[QUOTE="butisitbluray"]

[QUOTE="drakekratos"]

You probably think there is "nothing special" about this Gif either, despite the fact it looks like CGI even though it's real time.

mrmusicman247

i bet it's only 1 button gameplay though :D

Do you expect 10 button gameplay?

I don't see why people compare these 2 games. The ony thing similiar between the two is the cover system, and that's not even close.

The guy with the Susan Coffy signature is going out of his way to hate on Uncharted in every thread. HAters gonna hate i guessdrakekratos

haters gon' hate i suppose.

(Gifs here)

rumbalumba

GIF one - Whats impressive? Thats not new. Being able to do that with grenades is kinda old now. Oh, and the water isn't nearly as good the small picture wants you to think. Games like Crysis and JC2 have them beat easily.

GIF two - Whats the point of that one? Theres some lighting and shadows, neither which are groundbreaking or impressive, and Drake walks funky due to the ship moving.

GIF three - Some light beams and a take down. Impressive? No.

We know UC3 is gonna look good, but its not ground-breaking or anything. It's gonna be a UC2 with some polish and new effects.

[QUOTE="mitu123"][QUOTE="el3m2tigre"]

I don't see why people compare these 2 games. The ony thing similiar between the two is the cover system, and that's not even close.

sethman410

[QUOTE="rumbalumba"]

haters gon' hate i suppose.

(Gifs here)

ChubbyGuy40

We know UC3 is gonna look good, but its not ground-breaking or anything. It's gonna be a UC2 with some polish and new effects.

[QUOTE="sethman410"][QUOTE="mitu123"] That's probably the reason.mitu123

Oh, come on now. Action adventure? Let's make a poll thread about this, is it a TPS or Action Adventure? You make one, and see who's right. :twisted:

Ok people, we get it. Uncharted 3> Gears 3.

Now can we move on to another topic?

This is so biased. Every single gracphic element that Uncharted wins, you bash on Gears 3. Totally disagree.

The guy with the Susan Coffy signature is going out of his way to hate on Uncharted in every thread. HAters gonna hate i guessdrakekratos

Yeah, but you are hating on Gears 3, so its even.

[QUOTE="rumbalumba"]

haters gon' hate i suppose.

(Gifs here)

ChubbyGuy40

GIF one - Whats impressive? Thats not new. Being able to do that with grenades is kinda old now. Oh, and the water isn't nearly as good the small picture wants you to think. Games like Crysis and JC2 have them beat easily.

GIF two - Whats the point of that one? Theres some lighting and shadows, neither which are groundbreaking or impressive, and Drake walks funky due to the ship moving.

GIF three - Some light beams and a take down. Impressive? No.

We know UC3 is gonna look good, but its not ground-breaking or anything. It's gonna be a UC2 with some polish and new effects.

so what, the topic is about UC3 and Gears 3. why do pc gamers always bring up pc games in a console-games thread? they are like the "me too" guys of this gen. games talk about Gears 3 and UC3, hermits go "oh us too us too! look at Crysis! oh oh let us join too!" geezus christ.

so what if anything is not new? did we say UC3 is innovative? it's a graphics thread of Gears 3 and UC3. in fact, Gears 3 is Gears 1.02. how about that?

haters gon' hate i suppose.

[QUOTE="drakekratos"]The guy with the Susan Coffy signature is going out of his way to hate on Uncharted in every thread. HAters gonna hate i guessGOGOGOGURT

Yeah, but you are hating on Gears 3, so its even.

so what, the topic is about UC3 and Gears 3. why do pc gamers always bring up pc games in a console-games thread? they are like the "me too" guys of this gen. games talk about Gears 3 and UC3, hermits go "oh us too us too! look at Crysis! oh oh let us join too!" geezus christ.

so what if anything is not new? did we say UC3 is innovative? it's a graphics thread of Gears 3 and UC3. in fact, Gears 3 is Gears 1.02. how about that?

haters gon' hate i suppose.

rumbalumba

If Gears 3 is Gears 1.02

Uncharted 3 must be Uncharted 1.01.

Oh, and I bring up PC games because consolites love to hype games like this as the second comming in graphics when its all just flash. I guess when you sit 10ft away from a small screen its hard to see though. That, any anytime they post pictures/gifs about these graphics they aren't even in-game or during a cutscene.

Your right, haters gonna hate they can't catch up to 2007.

Cows have reached a new low. Both games will look great. Personally I think Gears 3 looks better but who really cares which game edges out the other when Gears 3 is going to be 10x more funshadow8585

[QUOTE="shadow8585"]Cows have reached a new low. Both games will look great. Personally I think Gears 3 looks better but who really cares which game edges out the other when Gears 3 is going to be 10x more funDCSullyvan

[QUOTE="rumbalumba"]

so what, the topic is about UC3 and Gears 3. why do pc gamers always bring up pc games in a console-games thread? they are like the "me too" guys of this gen. games talk about Gears 3 and UC3, hermits go "oh us too us too! look at Crysis! oh oh let us join too!" geezus christ.

so what if anything is not new? did we say UC3 is innovative? it's a graphics thread of Gears 3 and UC3. in fact, Gears 3 is Gears 1.02. how about that?

haters gon' hate i suppose.

ChubbyGuy40

If Gears 3 is Gears 1.02

Uncharted 3 must be Uncharted 1.01.

Oh, and I bring up PC games because consolites love to hype games like this as the second comming in graphics when its all just flash. I guess when you sit 10ft away from a small screen its hard to see though. That, any anytime they post pictures/gifs about these graphics they aren't even in-game or during a cutscene.

Your right, haters gonna hate they can't catch up to 2007.

keep telling yourself that to make you feel better. sorry to disappoint you, but these are from UC3, in-game, in-engine.

[QUOTE="ChubbyGuy40"]

[QUOTE="rumbalumba"]

haters gon' hate i suppose.

(Gifs here)

rumbalumba

GIF one - Whats impressive? Thats not new. Being able to do that with grenades is kinda old now. Oh, and the water isn't nearly as good the small picture wants you to think. Games like Crysis and JC2 have them beat easily.

GIF two - Whats the point of that one? Theres some lighting and shadows, neither which are groundbreaking or impressive, and Drake walks funky due to the ship moving.

GIF three - Some light beams and a take down. Impressive? No.

We know UC3 is gonna look good, but its not ground-breaking or anything. It's gonna be a UC2 with some polish and new effects.

in fact, Gears 3 is Gears 1.02. how about that?

If you actually think that, you're out of your damn mind.

[QUOTE="rumbalumba"]

in fact, Gears 3 is Gears 1.02. how about that?

DarkLink77

If you actually think that, you're out of your damn mind.

the other guy is ranting about how UC3 won't be groundbreaking or innovating. no one has even said anything about UC3 being groundbreaking in this thread. he was the only guy putting words in our mouth. it's a Gears 3 vs UC3 graphics thread, yet he barges in with "omg UC3 isnt that great! it's not groundbreaking at all! look at all those gifs, they have been done before!"

uhhh...no one ever said it wasnt done before. it's not like Gears 3 is groundbreaking either. UC3 has more gameplay mechanics than Gears 1, 2, and 3 combined.

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"]

[QUOTE="rumbalumba"]

in fact, Gears 3 is Gears 1.02. how about that?

rumbalumba

If you actually think that, you're out of your damn mind.

the other guy is ranting about how UC3 won't be groundbreaking or innovating. no one has even said anything about UC3 being groundbreaking in this thread. he was the only guy putting words in our mouth. it's a Gears 3 vs UC3 graphics thread, yet he barges in with "omg UC3 isnt that great! it's not groundbreaking at all! look at all those gifs, they have been done before!"

uhhh...no one ever said it wasnt done before. it's not like Gears 3 is groundbreaking either. UC3 has more gameplay mechanics than Gears 1, 2, and 3 combined.

keep telling yourself that to make you feel better. sorry to disappoint you, but these are from UC3, in-game, in-engine.

rumbalumba

Really? So when do you actually get to play during the game instead of watching cutscenes? Why not post something where its actually in-game and hes doing something...not just panning a camera or watching a cut-scene.

Cows have reached a new low. Both games will look great. Personally I think Gears 3 looks better but who really cares which game edges out the other when Gears 3 is going to be 10x more funshadow8585

You can't really pull the "new low" card here, not in SW. There is not only no "too low" here, but bragging about exclusively beautiful games is something that happens an awful lot.

I don't know if you've missed the hundreds of hermits posting pics of Crysis or Metro 2033, or if you missed when Gears of War back in 2006 was a thing, or if you just don't remember Uncharted 2 and the Killzone games on PS3.

But yeah, this happens a lot.

the other guy is ranting about how UC3 won't be groundbreaking or innovating. no one has even said anything about UC3 being groundbreaking in this thread. he was the only guy putting words in our mouth. it's a Gears 3 vs UC3 graphics thread, yet he barges in with "omg UC3 isnt that great! it's not groundbreaking at all! look at all those gifs, they have been done before!"

uhhh...no one ever said it wasnt done before. it's not like Gears 3 is groundbreaking either. UC3 has more gameplay mechanics than Gears 1, 2, and 3 combined.

rumbalumba

Some of us are just tired of Sony fanboys flaunting gifs and pictures of cutscenes. I'm not putting words in your mouth, I'm just trying to find out why they are posting cutscenes. What are you trying to prove? Cutscene king? It'll never beat MGS4 in that aspect. Trying to say it'll have better cutscenes than Gears? Those can be pretty interesting too.

Can't we wait until the games are actually out? Yeah, you're the only one thats posted some gameplay, but trying to post something that you don't play as passing it off as gameplay is well...rather quite annoying.

[QUOTE="rumbalumba"]

keep telling yourself that to make you feel better. sorry to disappoint you, but these are from UC3, in-game, in-engine.

ChubbyGuy40

Really? So when do you actually get to play during the game instead of watching cutscenes? Why not post something where its actually in-game and hes doing something...not just panning a camera or watching a cut-scene.

HA. so just because the camera pans out and the game controls Drake for a moment, you would just discard it? that what it looks like in the game. just because you're not controlling him during these epic moments does not mean that graphics does not look like that. IT DOES. you just dont control him for a brief moment because it's going for a cinematic feel, it's the way Naughty Dog wants to present these moments in the game.

'bu..bu..but you don't control him!' have you been living under a rock or something? oh no, i cant control Mario when he's climbing down that pipe! i can only see him gradually go down and i just have to wait for him to drop underground! pathetic.

here you go

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mwywuVzrJTg

that does not even give justice since Youtube has a crappy HD stream.

[QUOTE="rumbalumba"]

the other guy is ranting about how UC3 won't be groundbreaking or innovating. no one has even said anything about UC3 being groundbreaking in this thread. he was the only guy putting words in our mouth. it's a Gears 3 vs UC3 graphics thread, yet he barges in with "omg UC3 isnt that great! it's not groundbreaking at all! look at all those gifs, they have been done before!"

uhhh...no one ever said it wasnt done before. it's not like Gears 3 is groundbreaking either. UC3 has more gameplay mechanics than Gears 1, 2, and 3 combined.

ChubbyGuy40

Some of us are just tired of Sony fanboys flaunting gifs and pictures of cutscenes. I'm not putting words in your mouth, I'm just trying to find out why they are posting cutscenes. What are you trying to prove? Cutscene king? It'll never beat MGS4 in that aspect. Trying to say it'll have better cutscenes than Gears? Those can be pretty interesting too.

Can't we wait until the games are actually out? Yeah, you're the only one thats posted some gameplay, but trying to post something that you don't play as passing it off as gameplay is well...rather quite annoying.

just because you dont control Drake for a second does not mean it is not part of the gameplay.

that part where he jumps tot he plane? that happens during the game, it is not a separate cutscene. you press jump, and he does that, and the camera pans out and he does those animations for a cinematic feel. it happened in UC1 and UC2. 'oh..oh..but you dont cotrol him! it's a cutscene!' no, it's not. it's a 3-second screen to give the game a more epic feel, and after those 3 seconds the camera pans back to where it once was and you control Drake again, in the same place, in real time.

'omg have you played the game? how can you tell that?' then, have you? ive palyed enough Uncharted to know that Naughty Dog does this in every damn Uncahrted game out there.

[QUOTE="ChubbyGuy40"]

[QUOTE="rumbalumba"]

the other guy is ranting about how UC3 won't be groundbreaking or innovating. no one has even said anything about UC3 being groundbreaking in this thread. he was the only guy putting words in our mouth. it's a Gears 3 vs UC3 graphics thread, yet he barges in with "omg UC3 isnt that great! it's not groundbreaking at all! look at all those gifs, they have been done before!"

uhhh...no one ever said it wasnt done before. it's not like Gears 3 is groundbreaking either. UC3 has more gameplay mechanics than Gears 1, 2, and 3 combined.

rumbalumba

Some of us are just tired of Sony fanboys flaunting gifs and pictures of cutscenes. I'm not putting words in your mouth, I'm just trying to find out why they are posting cutscenes. What are you trying to prove? Cutscene king? It'll never beat MGS4 in that aspect. Trying to say it'll have better cutscenes than Gears? Those can be pretty interesting too.

Can't we wait until the games are actually out? Yeah, you're the only one thats posted some gameplay, but trying to post something that you don't play as passing it off as gameplay is well...rather quite annoying.

just because you dont control Drake for a second does not mean it is not part of the gameplay.

that part where he jumps tot he plane? that happens during the game, it is not a separate cutscene. you press jump, and he does that, and the camera pans out and he does those animations for a cinematic feel. it happened in UC1 and UC2. 'oh..oh..but you dont cotrol him! it's a cutscene!' no, it's not. it's a 3-second screen to give the game a more epic feel, and after those 3 seconds the camera pans back to where it once was and you control Drake again, in the same place, in real time.

'omg have you played the game? how can you tell that?' then, have you? ive palyed enough Uncharted to know that Naughty Dog does this in every damn Uncahrted game out there.

Who's the one putting words in peoples mouth? I wasn't even gonna say any of that :lol:

The best fun I had playing Uncharted 2 was actually playing it. Climbing walls, running through Shambala, fighting my way to the train. I always got pissed when it was another forced cutscene, because I feel theres too many of them. Why haven't they shown more gameplay yet? Yeah watching Drake pull-off death defying jumps and moments is cool, but know whats even better? When you're actually playing the game. It feels like they're gonna put even more emphasis on cutscenes and non-gameplay moments, then letting us play. In Gears, at least I know I'll be getting many hours of gameplay instead of watching them do "epic" scenes. If I wanted to pop in a game only to not play it, I'd throw in MGS4. Also, I've gotten to play Gears 3 already and know it looks damn good just on MP. Its more impressive than the Uncharted 3 footage shown at E3.

Oh, and that was a terrible comparison. Mario has 10x more gameplay scenes and doesn't use higher quality visuals during cutscenes. ;)

[QUOTE="rumbalumba"]

just because you dont control Drake for a second does not mean it is not part of the gameplay.

that part where he jumps tot he plane? that happens during the game, it is not a separate cutscene. you press jump, and he does that, and the camera pans out and he does those animations for a cinematic feel. it happened in UC1 and UC2. 'oh..oh..but you dont cotrol him! it's a cutscene!' no, it's not. it's a 3-second screen to give the game a more epic feel, and after those 3 seconds the camera pans back to where it once was and you control Drake again, in the same place, in real time.

'omg have you played the game? how can you tell that?' then, have you? ive palyed enough Uncharted to know that Naughty Dog does this in every damn Uncahrted game out there.

ChubbyGuy40

Who's the one putting words in peoples mouth? I wasn't even gonna say any of that :lol:

The best fun I had playing Uncharted 2 was actually playing it. Climbing walls, running through Shambala, fighting my way to the train. I always got pissed when it was another forced cutscene, because I feel theres too many of them. Why haven't they shown more gameplay yet? Yeah watching Drake pull-off death defying jumps and moments is cool, but know whats even better? When you're actually playing the game. It feels like they're gonna put even more emphasis on cutscenes and non-gameplay moments, then letting us play. In Gears, at least I know I'll be getting many hours of gameplay instead of watching them do "epic" scenes. If I wanted to pop in a game only to not play it, I'd throw in MGS4. Also, I've gotten to play Gears 3 already and know it looks damn good just on MP. Its more impressive than the Uncharted 3 footage shown at E3.

Oh, and that was a terrible comparison. Mario has 10x more gameplay scenes and doesn't use higher quality visuals during cutscenes. ;)

wow, you said "post gamepaly, not cutscenes!"

i said those are not cutscenes, but those 3-second moments in-between gameplay that happen in real time.

and this is a graphics thread of UC3 and Gears 3.

you say those are not gameplay, i say they are part of real-time gameplay, so it qualifies as in-game graphics. what's your point, now? you're getting tired of people posting these "cutscenes", yet these "cutscenes" happen in real-time during the game. so, just because you dont control your character is that split second, it does not qualify for a graphics thread? even if everything is happening in real-time?

and now you're talking about gameplay. this thread is not about gameplay. it's about UC3 vs Gears 3 graphics. i dont care if you're annoyed that we post thee gifs, but they're part of UC3, and they are not just some cutscenes. no one cares about who does what gameplay here, because were talking about graphics. gameplay is subjective.

wow, you said "post gamepaly, not cutscenes!"

rumbalumba

And I said you were the only one to actually post some gameplay. Maybe you should read it better.

i said those are not cutscenes, but those 3-second moments in-between gameplay that happen in real time.

rumbalumba

I know. Maybe you should read it over where I said "they should be focusing on adding more gameplay," and I forgot to mention "Where you have full control." Probably just me, but I don't think it should be "Stand here/wait here then press X to make something awesome happen." The player should have more control over it (as in he has to actually sprint to get to that far away ledge, not make some impossible leap with just one hand while dangling above certain death.)

and this is a graphics thread of UC3 and Gears 3.

rumbalumba

I know. I said Gears 3 looked better just in MP from what I've seen in UC3.

you say those are not gameplay, i say they are part of real-time gameplay, so it qualifies as in-game graphics. what's your point, now?

rumbalumba

Its a lot easier to make graphics better when everything is static and you have no control over it. Oh, did I mention Uncharted is only second to Killzone 2 when using blur on every single little thing they can? How can people actually put up with that? Every single time Drake moves, even if hes walking, theres a blur-filter put over his entire body.

you're getting tired of people posting these "cutscenes", yet these "cutscenes" happen in real-time during the game. so, just because you dont control your character is that split second, it does not qualify for a graphics thread? even if everything is happening in real-time?

rumbalumba

Go back and re-read the entire thread. Also look at that gif again where he's jumping onto the aircraft. Notice the slight freeze right before he lands? Do you notice the drop in quality right as he lands? (Obviously its loading the next part of the level, but point still stands.) Also go watch the trailer where the gif was taken from. When hes going up to the aircraft, it looks no where near as good. In fact, it looks just like Uncharted 2. At least Gears 3 did another overhaul on its visuals.

and now you're talking about gameplay. this thread is not about gameplay. it's about UC3 vs Gears 3 graphics. i dont care if you're annoyed that we post thee gifs, but they're part of UC3, and they are not just some cutscenes. no one cares about who does what gameplay here, because were talking about graphics. gameplay is subjective.

rumbalumba

Again, go back and re-read the thread. The TC used nothing but (Except 2 pics) cutscenes/non-gameplay moments. Why argue about visuals against another game, when you aren't even showing what it really looks like when playing. He hasn't even posted any gears 3 shots, and calls everyone who disagrees a fanboy.

Clearly Uncharted 3 looks soooooo much better because it's exclusive to the most powerfull system PS3.

gears 3 still looks decent though.

[QUOTE="mrmusicman247"]

[QUOTE="butisitbluray"]

i bet it's only 1 button gameplay though :D

mitu123

Do you expect 10 button gameplay?