This topic is locked from further discussion.
[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"]Lost and Damned already has received AAAE status on Gamerankings.Rhubarb9
[QUOTE="Rhubarb9"]
[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"]Lost and Damned already has received AAAE status on Gamerankings.Stevo_the_gamer
I see you have no retort. Perhaps you should have chosen your words more carefully, mate. Gamespot supposedly doesn't review DLC (even though they have in the past -- looking at you Xbox 360: Shivering Isles), so thus other means must be used to make up for that; hence, GR or Metacritic comes into play.
ALL those posts in system wars and you don't know the rules!?
dear god Steve...
only gamespot scores are counted on systemwarsRhubarb9
I see you have no retort. Perhaps you should have chosen your words more carefully, mate. Gamespot supposedly doesn't review DLC (even though they have in the past -- looking at you Xbox 360: Shivering Isles), so thus other means must be used to make up for that; hence, GR or Metacritic comes into play.[QUOTE="Rhubarb9"]
ALL those posts in system wars and you don't know the rules!?
dear god Steve...
only gamespot scores are counted on systemwarsStevo_the_gamer
I understand you're upset but we can't just let content DLC into all this
it's unfair towards all the PS3 DLC you find on PSN and whatever wii has
I see you have no retort. Perhaps you should have chosen your words more carefully, mate. Gamespot supposedly doesn't review DLC (even though they have in the past -- looking at you Xbox 360: Shivering Isles), so thus other means must be used to make up for that; hence, GR or Metacritic comes into play. They should review DLC... I'm sure there's a way they could at least categorize games and expansion packs differently. If they did that, I think it would eliminate the whole controversy about it. What would be the problem in giving an expansion a 9.0 if people knew that it was for an EXPANSION. More and more games are getting expansions, so GS needs to get with the times. 8)[QUOTE="Rhubarb9"]
ALL those posts in system wars and you don't know the rules!?
dear god Steve...
only gamespot scores are counted on systemwarsStevo_the_gamer
I understand you're upset but we can't just let content DLC into all thisUpset? Oh yeah, I forgot -- the internet is serious business. *waits for serious business pic*it's unfair towards all the PS3 DLC you find on PSN and whatever wii has
Rhubarb9
Nah, mate -- I'm trying to his this with *shocking for SystemWars, I know* logic and precise reasoning.
It would be unfair? So it's unfair that Shivering Isles were reviewed and this wasn't? I completely and utterly AGREE!
They should review DLC... I'm sure there's a way they could at least categorize games and expansion packs differently. If they did that, I think it would eliminate the whole controversy about it. What would be the problem in giving an expansion a 9.0 if people knew that it was for an EXPANSION. More and more games are getting expansions, so GS needs to get with the times. 8)They do review DLC content, hell, Shivering Isles anyone? The only way they could play it was by via download, nothing else. period. A retail form didn't come out until 6 to 8 months later after the review. Hell, Gamespot even did a news story about it finally coming to retail. I hate the hypocrisy. I agree with you though. :Pcarljohnson3456
Lost and Damned already has received AAAE status on Gamerankings.Stevo_the_gamer
Have you become like the Cows, trying to use other sites like they did for Uncharted, etc?
Gamespot is Gamespot, buddy.
You should go back to knocking MLB09: The Show away from Cows, or bashing KZ2, because this just won't work.
[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"]Lost and Damned already has received AAAE status on Gamerankings.SolidTy
Have you become like the Cows, trying to use other sites like they did for Uncharted, etc?
Gamespot is Gamespot, buddy.
You should go back to knocking MLB09: The Show away from Cows, or bashing KZ2, because this just won't work.
Too bad Uncharted was never AAA on Gamerankings -- just shy by a few hundreds of a percent so by them using it made no difference at all. I've always used GR or Metacritic since ... 2007 I believe. Why anyone takes Gamespot's word as the "word of God" is incomprehensible -- but hey, those of you who do, MGS4 is truly technically superior to Crysis... I mean, nothing can beat MGS4. :roll: Bashing Killzone 2? When did I EVER bash Killzone 2? :|[QUOTE="SolidTy"][QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"]Lost and Damned already has received AAAE status on Gamerankings.Stevo_the_gamer
Have you become like the Cows, trying to use other sites like they did for Uncharted, etc?
Gamespot is Gamespot, buddy.
You should go back to knocking MLB09: The Show away from Cows, or bashing KZ2, because this just won't work.
Too bad Uncharted was never AAA on Gamerankings -- just shy by a few hundreds of a percent so by them using it made no difference at all. I've always used GR or Metacritic since ... 2007 I believe. Why anyone takes Gamespot's word as the "word of God" is incomprehensible -- but hey, those of you who do, MGS4 is truly technically superior to Crysis... I mean, nothing can beat MGS4. :roll: Bashing Killzone 2? When did I EVER bash Killzone 2? :|Okay, I confused you with someone else about KZ2, and here's a secret, I don't go by GS's scores either, it's just part of the META GAME we play here in SW is all.
Okay, I confused you with someone else about KZ2, and here's a secret, I don't go by GS's scores either, it's just part of the META GAME we play here in SW is all.I see -- no worries, mate. The problem with this is that there is no review to go off of, no score to either complain or praise about... so the only logical place to go to would be GR or Metacritic to get what the general consensus is. That's all I did... Gamespot scores matter here, yes, but what is there is no Gamespot score.. the game just doesn't exist?SolidTy
I see -- no worries, mate. The problem with this is that there is no review to go off of, no score to either complain or praise about... so the only logical place to go to would be GR or Metacritic to get what the general consensus is. That's all I did... Gamespot scores matter here, yes, but what is there is no Gamespot score.. the game just doesn't exist?[QUOTE="SolidTy"]Okay, I confused you with someone else about KZ2, and here's a secret, I don't go by GS's scores either, it's just part of the META GAME we play here in SW is all.
Stevo_the_gamer
IT seems to fall in that dark void where Lost Winds, World of Goo, Braid, Flower, Castle Crashers, Super Stardust HD, Ratchet Booty, and so on fall in.
Um, Perfect Dark 2 might come out this year, and if it's like PDZ, then it'll get AAA here, so that'll be 3 AAAs for Lems, they need another one.[QUOTE="mitu123"][QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"]The 360 will get 2 AAAE Titles this year. ODST and Forza 3. The PS3 will get 4 AAAE Titles this year. Killzone 2, God of War 3, Uncharted 2 and InFAMOUS. Watch Infamous in Action http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OIo6y7VhOKc. My hype was AA but after this my hype is AAA.Rhubarb9
Halo ODST probably. Or Forza 3.Floppy_JimForza is a wanabe Grand Turismo. Since Halo sucks ODST is garbage too. But all the HAlo fans that dont realize KZ2 is 3 times the game will ge it and sales will soar. Halo and Gears are the only reason 360 has sold any consoles at all. Forza willl not get AAAE and ODST is add on content so it wont either.
[QUOTE="Rhubarb9"]
[QUOTE="mitu123"] Um, Perfect Dark 2 might come out this year, and if it's like PDZ, then it'll get AAA here, so that'll be 3 AAAs for Lems, they need another one.mitu123
[QUOTE="mitu123"]I think Uncharted 2 might be AAA, but I hope Heavy Rain gets AAA, even though it's most likely an AA and is one of the few PS3 exclusives I'm interested in over every other game this year. I don't think MAG could get AAA, it seems like Warhawk with more players. Oh, for 360, if Rare decides to reveal Killer Instinct 3, it could get AAA.Uncharted 2 will get a AAAE for sure same with Heavy Rain. Uncharted 2 has a chance at AAAAE i think based on what ive read and seen of the game. GOW3 is PS3s next in the bag AAAAE. God of War 3, maybe, Uncharted 2, with the way Gamespot review games, that's highly unlikely, but if it does get AAAA, I will accept ownage.[QUOTE="Rhubarb9"]
add uncharted 2, heavy rain and MAG to the PS3 exclusivesdjsifer01
[QUOTE="hoosier7"]End of the year with Forza or ODST, but by then the PS3 could have 2 more AAAEyoyo462001Those being? uncharted 2, godof war 3, heavy rain, infamous(probably AA IMO)
Gamespot reviews expansions, and DLC's are not expansions, but more like mini expansions if anything. If you look at past expansions like brood war, frozen throne, or any WoW expansions, they add a lot more to the gameplay and longevity of the originals. DLC's currently I think only add a few more hours to the gameplay. And Shivering Isles, don't quote me on this, is more of an expansion I think. Halo ODST will get reviewed because its an expansion. But whether it will be reviewed well is another question.
[QUOTE="mitu123"]I think Uncharted 2 might be AAA, but I hope Heavy Rain gets AAA, even though it's most likely an AA and is one of the few PS3 exclusives I'm interested in over every other game this year. I don't think MAG could get AAA, it seems like Warhawk with more players. Oh, for 360, if Rare decides to reveal Killer Instinct 3, it could get AAA.Uncharted 2 will get a AAAE for sure same with Heavy Rain. Uncharted 2 has a chance at AAAAE i think based on what ive read and seen of the game. GOW3 is PS3s next in the bag AAAAE.[QUOTE="Rhubarb9"]
add uncharted 2, heavy rain and MAG to the PS3 exclusivesdjsifer01
Uncharted 2 is AA-AAAe range no doubt. Heavy Rain is a mix bag; it's trying some new, I'll give it that, but it could deliver or fall short much like Mirror's Edge. God of War won't be AAAAe, this I can say 100%.
Since Halo sucks ODST is garbage too.djsifer01Since we're talking about GS scores, your personal opinion of the game isn't too relevant to the discussion. GS has given AAA to all Bungie-developed Halo games except for the Halo 2 PC port, so there's not much reason to think ODST will flop.
360, I have no clue. Wii, I have equally no clue, maybe Tiger Woods? Looks to be doing some really good things this year. My personal AAA hyped game is Muramasa the Demon Blade. It's gonna take me forever just to get all 108 swords let alone everything else.
[QUOTE="Rhubarb9"]
[QUOTE="mitu123"] Um, Perfect Dark 2 might come out this year, and if it's like PDZ, then it'll get AAA here, so that'll be 3 AAAs for Lems, they need another one.mitu123
I think Uncharted 2 might be AAA, but I hope Heavy Rain gets AAA, even though it's most likely an AA and is one of the few PS3 exclusives I'm interested in over every other game this year. I don't think MAG could get AAA, it seems like Warhawk with more players. Oh, for 360, if Rare decides to reveal Killer Instinct 3, it could get AAA.I think Heavy Rain could be my best game this gen and surpasses MGS4 in awesomeness, Im anticipating this game more than anything else. Same here,Heavy Rain interests me more than any game this year, even Gran Turismo, that series hasn't been awesome since GT2 IMO.[QUOTE="mitu123"]
[QUOTE="Rhubarb9"]
add uncharted 2, heavy rain and MAG to the PS3 exclusivesHAZE-Unit
[QUOTE="beast667"]Why are cows so cocky, this time last year you had no AAAE at all.Rhubarb9
How do you expect us to know? Are we fortune-tellers? (right answer: we aren't.)
[QUOTE="Rhubarb9"]
[QUOTE="beast667"]Why are cows so cocky, this time last year you had no AAAE at all.IronBass
How do you expect us to know? Are we fortune-tellers? (right answer: we aren't.)
but we saw KZ2 scoring AAA from 4 years back
I'm just trying to find out whats on the horizon
what I've gathered is thers absolutely nothing and that they are waiting for the 2 game conferences to announce super secret RARE game sequels or perfect dark zero 2
but we saw KZ2 scoring AAA from 4 years backRhubarb9We sure did. :| :lol: Maybe my sarcasm detector is broken... you can't be serious. At least, I HOPE you're not serious.
[QUOTE="IronBass"]
[QUOTE="Rhubarb9"]
what do you mean cocky? stop living in the past...
short, honest and simple question
when will X360 get AAAE 2009?Rhubarb9
How do you expect us to know? Are we fortune-tellers? (right answer: we aren't.)
but we saw KZ2 scoring AAA from 4 years back
I'm just trying to find out whats on the horizon
what I've gathered is thers absolutely nothing and that they are waiting for the 2 game conferences to announce super secret RARE game sequels or perfect dark zero 2
Rhubarb9
but we saw KZ2 scoring AAA from 4 years back
I'm just trying to find out whats on the horizon
what I've gathered is thers absolutely nothing and that they are waiting for the 2 game conferences to announce super secret RARE game sequels or perfect dark zero 2
I guess you haven't gathered that much.
but we saw KZ2 scoring AAA from 4 years backRhubarb9Yeah, because we were 100% sure it would score AAA :roll:
Yeah, because we were 100% sure it would score AAA :roll:[QUOTE="IronBass"][QUOTE="Rhubarb9"]but we saw KZ2 scoring AAA from 4 years backRhubarb9
Hyping is like a gamble. You never "know" what will happen.
None "knew" KZ2 would score AAA, no one "knew" Gears would score AAA.
[QUOTE="SolidTy"]
[QUOTE="jjenkins78x"] Is ODST even a full game? I am sure Gamespot will rescind it's "we don't review expansion packs" policy to give a Halo game a 10.5. On the topic of ODST, what a GOD AWFUL NAME. Orbital Drop Shock Trooper? What the fu- seriously? 100 bucks most of the people that buy it can't even pronounce the name. I'll also take side bets that the box art makes it look like Master Chief is in the game. jjenkins78x
The game will be good, but I do agree, It's a godawful title.
Halo 3 Recon was lame, but now, inretrospect, I wish it would come back. Halo 3 ODST doesn't roll off the tongue at all.
They should call it Halo 3-Con. Or just be honest and call it Halo WTF Does It Matter You're Going to Buy It Anyway.
Haha let's hijack this thread which is borderline trolling anyway, and come up with better names for the new Halo game.
Halo: Any Questions?
Halo ODST: Shut Up and Buy Me Edition
Halo: What's In a Name?
HaLOL All Ur Money R Belong 2 Us
Halo: Printing Money
Halo Mountain Dew: The Game
^^^
Pure win.
[QUOTE="Rhubarb9"]
[QUOTE="IronBass"] Yeah, because we were 100% sure it would score AAA :roll:IronBass
Hyping is like a gamble. You never "know" what will happen.
None "knew" KZ2 would score AAA, no one "knew" Gears would score AAA.
[QUOTE="IronBass"]
None "knew" KZ2 would score AAA, no one "knew" Gears would score AAA.
Rhubarb9
I think your gut must be going through a time-warp cause there's already been an AAAE although it's only DLC. As for full games, even though L+D is considered one to most who've played it, Splinter Cell Convictions' last known release date is scheduled late June but that may be postponed you never know with that game. Other than that for the FIRST half I don't see anything else either ATM.
[QUOTE="jjenkins78x"]
[QUOTE="SolidTy"]
The game will be good, but I do agree, It's a godawful title.Halo 3 Recon was lame, but now, inretrospect, I wish it would come back. Halo 3 ODST doesn't roll off the tongue at all.
ANeuralPathway
They should call it Halo 3-Con. Or just be honest and call it Halo WTF Does It Matter You're Going to Buy It Anyway.
Haha let's hijack this thread which is borderline trolling anyway, and come up with better names for the new Halo game.
Halo: Any Questions?
Halo ODST: Shut Up and Buy Me Edition
Halo: What's In a Name?
HaLOL All Ur Money R Belong 2 Us
Halo: Printing Money
Halo Mountain Dew: The Game
^^^
Pure win.
Did you read my post? I responded to his list...:)
--------------------
Halo 3 : Human Edition
Halo 3.5...Finish the Transaction.
Halo 3 : No more Chief
Halo 3 and a half...men
Olah E (Halo 3 backwards)
Halo 3 : Expanding Halo's Halo
Halo 3 : Halo Part four
Halo : MCIGBMIG (Master Chief is green because Money is green)
[QUOTE="ANeuralPathway"]
[QUOTE="jjenkins78x"]
They should call it Halo 3-Con. Or just be honest and call it Halo WTF Does It Matter You're Going to Buy It Anyway.
Haha let's hijack this thread which is borderline trolling anyway, and come up with better names for the new Halo game.
Halo: Any Questions?
Halo ODST: Shut Up and Buy Me Edition
Halo: What's In a Name?
HaLOL All Ur Money R Belong 2 Us
Halo: Printing Money
Halo Mountain Dew: The Game
SolidTy
^^^
Pure win.
Did you read my post? I responded to his list...:)
I did just now, yours is also pure win.
[QUOTE="SolidTy"]
[QUOTE="ANeuralPathway"]
^^^
Pure win.
ANeuralPathway
Did you read my post? I responded to his list...:)
-------------------------
Halo 3 : Human Edition
Halo 3.5...Finish the Transaction.
Halo 3 : No more Chief
Halo 3 and a half...men
Olah E (Halo 3 backwards)
Halo 3 : Expanding Halo's Halo
Halo 3 : Halo Part four
Halo : MCIGBMIG (Master Chief is green because Money is green)
I did just now, yours is also pure win.
Yeah, it's a shame we didn't finish that. :P
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment