So many good choices! Tomb Raider was fantastic visually, Papers, Please was a great indie title, and man, the Stanley Parable was sooo good. Gone Home did an amazing job with it's storytelling, and Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons crafted such an emotional experience.
Honestly, I'd probably be happy with any of the choices above. but if I had to choose, I might chose Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons.
Great write-up, I could really visualize what playing the game will be like. That's too bad the immersion and character interactions aren't as polished or satisfying as they could have been, but the multiple endings and premise make it sound promising enough to pick up.
I bought a PS4 because traditionally I have always preferred Sony exclusives over Xbox ones, that and it brings the option of 1080p gaming to my living room, but really, I will likely only be using my PS4 to play console exclusive games, and will continue to play everything that is available for PC on PC.
PC Download isn't showing up on the main site. Perhaps it's because I just registered a new account and redeemed/linked my console version. I'll check back later.
Necrotron's comments