@cornbredx: People that don't own them and aren't fond of piracy? Or people that want to play them on a large screen but don't want bother with moving their PC?

Bring PS1 games too. I need Symphony of the Night and Final Fantasy Tactics on my PS4.

@Tyson8earzz: Nobody is forcing you to pay anything. If it's not worth it to you, don't pay it, really quite simple.

@jecomans: Don't understand the combat complaints at all. I loved the combat, it felt tight, responsive, and most importantly was fun. I feel like the people that complain about W3 combat are the same one's who complained about TLOU shooting, i.e. "It's not like COD! IT SUCKS!"

@jecomans: That's usually how I feel during open world games, but Witcher 3 was different for me, the side quests were so engrossing it just never got old. However there was maybe too many ?'s in the ocean in Skellige, those got a bit boring at times.

@i_am_battlecry: Well they weren't bad games, but not on the same level as these. Halo 5 and FM5 were the second lowest rated game in each series.

As it should have. There were a lot of great games this year, but the only truly incredible ones were Witcher 3 and Bloodborne.

@sladakrobot: I looked hard in my comment for quotations around disappearing, no luck.

@saturatedbutter: According to digital foundry, the frame rates are worse on X1. Watch the analysis video. I didn't say PS4 didn't have problems, just X! was worse.

While X1 has definitely improved, I feel like this is a bit generous. For instance, the performance gap is disappearing? Just Cause 3 was just released, and not only is the resolution higher on PS4, but the frame rate is better as well.

Also, the "strong" lineup of exclusive games is a bit generous as well. The latest Halo and FM installments, while not bad games by any means, were the 2nd worst rated in each series.