Edge Magazine's credibility has been VAPORIZED.

With just one phailed issue.

Mario Galaxy 10
Uncharted - 8
Assassins Creed - 7
Crysis - 9
Mass Effect - 7
Call of Duty 4 - 9
Kane and Lynch - 6
Tony Hawk: Proving Ground - 6
The Simpsons Game - 5
Zack and Wiki - 8
The Witcher - 5
Bladestorm - 8
Castlevania Dracula X - 7
Silent Hill 0rigins - 7
Hellgate: London - 6
Timeshift - 6
Mutant Storm Empire - 8
Guitar Hero III - 6
Beowulf - 5
Need For Speed: Prostreet - 6

www.rllmukforum.com

Bladestorm >>> Mass Effect? :|

Mutant Storm Empire >>> Mass Effect? :|

Beowulf = The Witcher? :|

Keep in mind, Bladestorm has not been reviewed here but is averaging 63% at GameRankings.com and Mutant Storm is averaging a 77%... while Mass Effect floats around 93% and of course a 8.5 here.

Is it just me, or does Edge Magazine need to no longer be quoted around these parts?

Lemmings = Owned with Mass Effect

I can see why someone would give it a 7.

The game was obviously rushed and unfinished, and it's combat system is bad.

I can see why someone would give it a 7.

The game was obviously rushed and unfinished, and it's combat system is bad.

Out_Kast3000

Because you've played it. mmmmkay thanks. 8.5 here and 93% overall.

I stopped trusting Edge's scores when they gave Odin Sphere and Phoenix Wright III a 6 and Prime 3 a 7.

Because you've played it. mmmmkay thanks. 8.5 here and 93% overall.

Dreams-Visions

You're acting as if review scores actually determine game quality instead of appeal.

maybe they just hated it. Holden1985

more than two games that sound like they took 2 weeks to make?

mass effect is way better than that

Lemmings = Owned with Mass Effect

I can see why someone would give it a 7.

The game was obviously rushed and unfinished, and it's combat system is bad.

Out_Kast3000

ok "out_Kast3000" *giggles*

No it hasn't been vaporized. Maybe they just didn't like it. And you can't really compare Bladstorm to Mass Effect. They're totally different games.FrozenLiquid

it's the principle of the matter to me.

[QUOTE="Out_Kast3000"]

I can see why someone would give it a 7.

The game was obviously rushed and unfinished, and it's combat system is bad.

Dreams-Visions

Because you've played it. mmmmkay thanks. 8.5 here and 93% overall.

Ratchet and Clank......

[QUOTE="FrozenLiquid"]No it hasn't been vaporized. Maybe they just didn't like it. And you can't really compare Bladstorm to Mass Effect. They're totally different games.Dreams-Visions

it's the principle of the matter to me.

[QUOTE="Dreams-Visions"][QUOTE="Out_Kast3000"]

I can see why someone would give it a 7.

The game was obviously rushed and unfinished, and it's combat system is bad.

-Serpahim-

Because you've played it. mmmmkay thanks. 8.5 here and 93% overall.

Ratchet and Clank......

What about it?

Every reviewer body have anomalies - GS have their share and so do Edge.

If everybody was scrutinised in the same way, then credibility has been vaporised totally, totally, in total.

I do approve of that 10 for Galaxy, though. 8)

game is bonkers.

[QUOTE="Dreams-Visions"]

[QUOTE="FrozenLiquid"]No it hasn't been vaporized. Maybe they just didn't like it. And you can't really compare Bladstorm to Mass Effect. They're totally different games.FrozenLiquid

it's the principle of the matter to me.

I'll have to think about this one. They scored BLADESTORM higher. BLADESTORM. :|

[QUOTE="Dreams-Visions"][QUOTE="Out_Kast3000"]

I can see why someone would give it a 7.

The game was obviously rushed and unfinished, and it's combat system is bad.

-Serpahim-

Because you've played it. mmmmkay thanks. 8.5 here and 93% overall.

Ratchet and Clank......

I see what you did there.

giving mass effect a 9.5 would be sending out a wrong message to the develeoprs. it's kie saying it's okay torelease games that are full of problems.

7 seems abit too hasrch however.

People used to care about Edge ? :lol:

[QUOTE="Out_Kast3000"]

I can see why someone would give it a 7.

The game was obviously rushed and unfinished, and it's combat system is bad.

Dreams-Visions

Because you've played it. mmmmkay thanks. 8.5 here and 93% overall.

WOW, you sound like the cows when ratchet flopped. Granted mass effect didn't flop as hard, but talk about hypocrits. Gamerankings doesn't count right?

[QUOTE="Dreams-Visions"][QUOTE="Out_Kast3000"]

I can see why someone would give it a 7.

The game was obviously rushed and unfinished, and it's combat system is bad.

WSP87

Because you've played it. mmmmkay thanks. 8.5 here and 93% overall.

WOW, you sound like the cows when ratchet flopped. Granted mass effect didn't flop as hard, but talk about hypocrits. Gamerankings doesn't count right?

No one is using this as ownage, bud.

I never even heard of Edge Magazine. How ever gamespot scores are right on the money and has the best reviewers out there.demoralizer

Nope Greg Kasavin isnt here anymore... :(

As far as i'm concerned their credibility was vaporized when they gave Metroid Prime 3 7/10 and then gave Halo 3 10/10.TheLordHimself

That's pretty much exactly correct. :|

"One reviewer disagreed with the general consensus therefore they are wrong." :cry:Ninja-Vox

Some people think the "whole" magazine/site give it that score :lol:

I do approve of that 10 for Galaxy, though. 8)

game is bonkers.

Dreams-Visions

yeah, me too

[QUOTE="FrozenLiquid"]No it hasn't been vaporized. Maybe they just didn't like it. And you can't really compare Bladstorm to Mass Effect. They're totally different games.Dreams-Visions

it's the principle of the matter to me.

Do you make these GIFs?

It is great, lol, and he looks like a character in ME.

As far as i'm concerned their credibility was vaporized when they gave Metroid Prime 3 7/10 and then gave Halo 3 10/10.TheLordHimself

Uh...thats because Halo 3 is superior in all aspects to Metroid Prime 3. :|

[QUOTE="Out_Kast3000"]

I can see why someone would give it a 7.

The game was obviously rushed and unfinished, and it's combat system is bad.

Dreams-Visions

Because you've played it. mmmmkay thanks. 8.5 here and 93% overall.

Dude dont mind him, he always bashes anything 360.

I myself am growing on the combat. Its not great but neither was KOTOR's combat and this game is basically KOTOR but different combat so far

And I love the film like look to it. If u play the game u know what I mean. It looks film like with a little grainyness to it, beautiful. I just wish they did KOTOR 3 cause I love the Star Wars universe... in terms of what is already in place etc..

[QUOTE="Dreams-Visions"]

[QUOTE="FrozenLiquid"]No it hasn't been vaporized. Maybe they just didn't like it. And you can't really compare Bladstorm to Mass Effect. They're totally different games.HAZE-Unit

it's the principle of the matter to me.

Do you make these GIFs?

It is great, lol, and he looks like a character in ME.

Indeed I do 8)

[QUOTE="Dreams-Visions"][QUOTE="Out_Kast3000"]

I can see why someone would give it a 7.

The game was obviously rushed and unfinished, and it's combat system is bad.

kcpp2b

Because you've played it. mmmmkay thanks. 8.5 here and 93% overall.

Dude dont mind him, he always bashes anything 360.

I myself am growing on the combat. Its not great but neither was KOTOR's combat and this game is basically KOTOR but different combat so far

And I love the film like look to it. If u play the game u know what I mean. It looks film like with a little grainyness to it, beautiful. I just wish they did KOTOR 3 cause I love the Star Wars universe... in terms of what is already in place etc..

I've notice you said don't mind the 360 basher, but I've seen you plenty of times support Yellow_Rose's topics. Interesting...

Uncharted - 8

Dreams-Visions

Edge Magazine's Credibility officially Lost .

[QUOTE="Dreams-Visions"]

Uncharted - 8

AgentA-Mi6

Edge Magazine's Credibility officially Lost .

I think an 8 is fair. a 9 would have been better, but an 8 is fair.

WTF is Mutant Storm Empire?....And Bladestorm: The 100 Years War better than Mass Effect?:lol: Yes indeed, vaporized is a perfect term for describing their credibility. ironcreed

When did Edge ever have credibility? :|

At least they got the SMG score tight 8)

At least they got the SMG score tight 8)

metalslug10

can't disagree there 8)

[QUOTE="AgentA-Mi6"][QUOTE="Dreams-Visions"]

Uncharted - 8

Dreams-Visions

Edge Magazine's Credibility officially Lost .

I think an 8 is fair. a 9 would have been better, but an 8 is fair.

Damn it man your sigs are are alwaysawsome