MLB 09: The Show 9.0 AAA - Gamespot Review Discussion

[QUOTE="Animal-Mother"][QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"]Yes, SystemWars decided that GRAW is exclusive.horrowhip

what are you talking about. GRAW is exclusive. No arguments about it.

its pure logicFurbyballistik

[QUOTE="Silverbond"]

[QUOTE="Furbyballistik"]im going to call this one exclusive. why? bcuz we dont use ps2 and psp in our AAAE debates. it should be considered AAAE, until we start using the ps2 in our debates again. if we did use ps2, then 360 wouldnt lead the charge anymore..amirite?Furbyballistik

So, Ninja Gaiden Sigma is an exclusive as well?

So, it doesn't matter how similar they are. If a game was released on a last-gen and current-gen system it's exclusive for the current-gen console?

That Thread clearly states that its not. PC/360 = Not exclsuive. its on PC its on 360 Animal-Mother

What is this damage control? I can't believe this made it to 550 posts. :D. I can't believe this unbelievable logic that because two gawmes play the same that means they are the same game. Is Madden 01 the same as Madden 09? Is halo 1 the same as halo 2. This debate is unbelievable. I mean if the game isn't the same exact thing than it is exclusive. There is no altering this idea. I mean wow.nhh18

exactly. Not exclusive. Because it IS the exact same thing except for the technical differences.

Unless you just gave the PC a ton more exclusives? TF2 PC exclusive, Gears of War PC exclusive, Mass Effect PC exclusive, Halo 2 PC exclusive...

Is this how we are doing it now? Technical differences=exclusives?

It's Sony exclusive, it's not Playstation 3 exclusive... like it matters anyway.Brainkiller05

[QUOTE="Animal-Mother"]That Thread clearly states that its not. PC/360 = Not exclsuive. its on PC its on 360 Stevo_the_gamer

[QUOTE="Furbyballistik"]its pure logicStevo_the_gamer

It's Sony exclusive, it's not Playstation 3 exclusive... like it matters anyway.Brainkiller05

Sony exclusives are as real as unicorns.

[QUOTE="horrowhip"]

[QUOTE="Animal-Mother"] And that thread decided that Graw is not exclusiveAnimal-Mother

what are you talking about. GRAW is exclusive. No arguments about it.

[QUOTE="Furbyballistik"]its pure logicStevo_the_gamer

And that thread decided that Graw is not exclusiveAnimal-Mother

what are you talking about. GRAW is exclusive. No arguments about it.

[QUOTE="Brainkiller05"]It's Sony exclusive, it's not Playstation 3 exclusive... like it matters anyway.Stevo_the_gamer

Well it is, Sony owns the game, but it is irrelevant because it is across 3 platforms. You need a vacation, you have been non stop arguing since Halo Wars haha.

[QUOTE="Brainkiller05"]It's Sony exclusive, it's not Playstation 3 exclusive... like it matters anyway.Stevo_the_gamer

It's Sony exclusive, it's not Playstation 3 exclusive... like it matters anyway.Brainkiller05

MLB 09 The Show = PS3 AAAE

/thread

W1NGMAN-

[QUOTE="Animal-Mother"][QUOTE="horrowhip"]

what are you talking about. GRAW is exclusive. No arguments about it.

Eddie-Vedder

MLB 09 The Show is not exclusive because you can get the same experience on different systems.

Fallout 3 has 93 (360) 91 (PS3) your reaching. Not to mention didn't a simple patch fix most of the issues? Eddie-Vedder

Fallout 3 (360) =9.0

Fallout 3 (Ps3) = 8.5

but what if this game is 6 years of technology difference?HAZE-Unit

[QUOTE="Brainkiller05"]It's Sony exclusive, it's not Playstation 3 exclusive... like it matters anyway.foxhound_fox

Yeah he already said it is not exclusive. He just meant it is Sony's game.

[QUOTE="Brainkiller05"]It's Sony exclusive, it's not Playstation 3 exclusive... like it matters anyway.foxhound_fox

No because its an action adventure game, Graw is still a tactical shooter either wayAnimal-Mother

[QUOTE="Brainkiller05"]It's Sony exclusive, it's not Playstation 3 exclusive... like it matters anyway.foxhound_fox

[QUOTE="Animal-Mother"]No because its an action adventure game, Graw is still a tactical shooter either wayStevo_the_gamer

[QUOTE="HAZE-Unit"]but what if this game is 6 years of technology difference?Stevo_the_gamer

[QUOTE="Soulja_West"][QUOTE="Bread_or_Decide"] Multiplatform refers to consoles owned by other companies. If the same company owns all of them. Its still exclusive. dk_2007

There is nothing like sony exclusive or company exclusive. Otherwise tell me which company owns PC? because I sure have heard about PC exclusive.

Only reasonable argument will be if you can show that the game on PS2 is vastly different from PS3. Though there are some points regarding this in the previous pages.

[QUOTE="foxhound_fox"]

[QUOTE="Brainkiller05"]It's Sony exclusive, it's not Playstation 3 exclusive... like it matters anyway.Eddie-Vedder

Nope, it proves its the superior version.

[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"][QUOTE="HAZE-Unit"]but what if this game is 6 years of technology difference?mitu123

[QUOTE="Furbyballistik"][QUOTE="Silverbond"]

So, Ninja Gaiden Sigma is an exclusive as well?

Silverbond

So, it doesn't matter how similar they are. If a game was released on a last-gen and current-gen system it's exclusive for the current-gen console?

What is this microsoft exclusive. They are the same exact game with lower or higher resolution textures/ AA. I mean it isn't like geometry, Artificial Intelligence, different Engines, different features, Online capability, and other features. I mean come on. nhh18

[QUOTE="Eddie-Vedder"]

[QUOTE="foxhound_fox"]
Then Halo, Halo 2, Fable and Gears of War are "Microsoft exclusive."

There is only one definition for the word "exclusive." And that is a unique game experience on one platform and no other.

Nagidar

Nope, it proves its the superior version.

[QUOTE="Animal-Mother"][QUOTE="horrowhip"]

what are you talking about. GRAW is exclusive. No arguments about it.

Eddie-Vedder

IT IS MORE THAN JUST THE SAME NAME.

Go out, rent the two games and run through the game modes comparing the two. Then play the two...

THEY ARE THE SAME GAME. If one more person says otherwise I am going to ****ing explode.

I SWEAR TO GOD you do not have a CLUE what you are talking about if you are trying to claim that MLB 09: The Show is exclusive. Because it is literally, the EXACT SAME GAME on the PS2 minus graphics. And throw on technical issues to the PS2 version...

y r u ignoring my full post? over here on SW we DONT count last gen games in our AAAE debates. so y isnt MLB being considered a PS3 exclusive if we stopped using last gen AAAs? in that case LoZ:TP shouldnt be considered AAE for Wii since it also released on GC, right? im just saying, it should only matter if last gen AAAs still counted.Furbyballistik

[QUOTE="HAZE-Unit"]but what if this game is 6 years of technology difference?Stevo_the_gamer

hypothetically, would you consider Final Fantasy VII remake on a current gen console exclusive or not?

I can't believe this turned into such a big debate.

Question: Before this was Legend of Zelda Twilight Princess ever considered a Wii exclusive?

Obviously it fits all the qualifications people are making for The Show. Only only version of it this gen, Slightly alterated gameplay, Brand Exclusive. Yet if I recall, TP was never considered an exclusive for the Wii even though it's a Brand Exclusive. Why should we start doing it now that Show is AAAe.

[QUOTE="Nagidar"]

[QUOTE="Eddie-Vedder"] Doesn't the fact that the PS3 version is at 89 MC, and the PS2 is 78 at MC prove the PS3 version is unique?

Eddie-Vedder

Nope, it proves its the superior version.

I haven't played the Wii version of DR, so I cannot comment on that, but GRAW on the 360 and PC were COMPLETELY different games, one a TPS, one a FPS, different settings and different story.

Anyways, you guys are missing the point, at the end of the day PS3 has an AAA game which 360 doesn't have... whether it's exclusive or not doesn't make it a better game and doesn't make it any more important.Brainkiller05

[QUOTE="Eddie-Vedder"]

[QUOTE="Nagidar"]

Nope, it proves its the superior version.

I haven't played the Wii version of DR, so I cannot comment on that, but GRAW on the 360 and PC were COMPLETELY different games, one a TPS, one a FPS, different settings anddifferent story.

I've only played the PS3 version and I don't have any reason to play the last gen versions, on the other hand people misses out if they didn't play the PS3 version after playing the last gen game. Yes it's exclusive.

hypothetically, would you consider Final Fantasy VII remake on a current gen console exclusive or not?HAZE-Unit

I can't believe this turned into such a big debate.

Question: Before this was Legend of Zelda Twilight Princess ever considered a Wii exclusive?

Obviously it fits all the qualifications people are making for The Show. Only only version of it this gen, Slightly alterated gameplay, Brand Exclusive. Yet if I recall, TP was never considered an exclusive for the Wii even though it's a Brand Exclusive. Why should we start doing it now that Show is AAAe.

Like Graw and Dead Rising?Eddie-Vedder

[QUOTE="Silverbond"]

[QUOTE="Furbyballistik"] yes if we exclude xbox, ps2, n GC in our SW AAAE debates....not AAAE if we do. its pure logicFurbyballistik

So, it doesn't matter how similar they are. If a game was released on a last-gen and current-gen system it's exclusive for the current-gen console?

As I said, it's exclusive for the current-gen console using your logic. Correct?

[QUOTE="Nagidar"]

[QUOTE="Eddie-Vedder"] Doesn't the fact that the PS3 version is at 89 MC, and the PS2 is 78 at MC prove the PS3 version is unique?

Eddie-Vedder

Nope, it proves its the superior version.

[QUOTE="HAZE-Unit"] I've only played the PS3 version and I don't have any reason to play the last gen versions, on the other hand people misses out if they didn't play the PS3 version after playing the last gen game. Yes it's exclusive.

hypothetically, would you consider Final Fantasy VII remake on a current gen console exclusive or not?Stevo_the_gamer

[QUOTE="WhySoSerious300"]

Nice!! Another Sony game that gets an AAAE. :D.

Toriko42

[QUOTE="Lionheart08"]

I can't believe this turned into such a big debate.

Question: Before this was Legend of Zelda Twilight Princess ever considered a Wii exclusive?

Obviously it fits all the qualifications people are making for The Show. Only only version of it this gen, Slightly alterated gameplay, Brand Exclusive. Yet if I recall, TP was never considered an exclusive for the Wii even though it's a Brand Exclusive. Why should we start doing it now that Show is AAAe.

HAZE-Unit

It is the same, with minro tweaks. TP is the same, with minor tweaks, such as waggle.