@CrownKingArthur said:
i haven't been keeping up with the play. in terms of recently released multiplats - does the PS4 still win every time?
not trying to rustle any jimmies, but as far as I recall PS4 is a very safe bet to have the superior multiplats.
now at the same time, to quote shakespeare 'It doesn't matter if you win by an inch or a mile, winning is winning', and from what I've seen - PS4 has routinely demonstrated superior graphics to XB1.
so, i guess where i'm going with this is this: even if your premise is true (thanks for the clarification btw), would that matter if the result was still superior multiplats for PS4?
i guess this might be a case of the tail wagging the dog.
Well not really since in gta V, you can have high speed chases without having fps drops, so in some cases the xboxone actually performs better. Games that will be cpu hogs will tend to run better on the x1 even if sony has a lot of tricks to let the gpu do cpu work, it will be a bottleneck forever, since gpu's aren't made to cpu work. If they actually manage to bridge that gap with the x1 in the cpu departement with the gpu, they will have less resources than the x1 for graphics. Don't forget it's a 7770 in there with a 256 bit bus connected straight to that esram. Because of that experts say the performance of the gpu in x1 is comparable to a hd 7790, and that is true. The difference between the hd 7790 and hd 7850 (ps4) is not that big.
The memory bandwith is not usefull as well, since the memory bandwith could only have an advantage for communication with the cpu, since it's bottlenecking, that doesn't help. You could say that it's usefull for the gpu, but that hd 7850 just needs that kind of bandwith, the x1 gpu doesn't since it has less shader cores and that esram isn't calculated within the main bandwith, so that gives a warped image.
The x1 is also 50$ cheaper and as a multimedia system the xboxone is better because it's way better at multitasking. Personally i prefer the x1 controller as well (but that's just a matter of taste) What i'm saying is, buying a ps4 for performance is ridiculous, since there's hardly any difference. It will not give you the better multiplat experience (or it is with lauch games). Some games may be marginally better, but some games will be marginally better on the x1 as well.
Sony is not very good at maximimizing performance on a console, the ps3 is a great example of it. Maybe sony will manage to do something extra late in this gen like with the last of us on the ps3, but the difference between the ps3 and x360 was way bigger than the difference between the ps4 and x1, so it's kinda hard to know what to expect, when to expect it and you'll be paying extra. At launch the ps4 was of course a way better deal if you didn't want a kinect but that time is long gone. You pay 350$ for a xboxone right now and they have some nice bundles.
Controller, exclusives, price and features is what should be your guidance for making a decision,
Log in to comment