[QUOTE="ianuilliam"]

[QUOTE="ForzaGearsFace"]More cows here lol of course uc winsForzaGearsFace

[QUOTE="kbanna"]

"and saying Sony lied"

Sorry for the huge quote in the other post. I said that Ign editor lied because he made it a point to come back and update with "Sony confirmed this is sold to customers" . I said then, and still maintain, that if the sell thru was even close to that , it would of been the largest exclusive launch this gen....not surprisingly that claim never popped up anywhere on the net. They sold it to stores, Gears and Halo sell it to customers. Thats why there are mid nite launch parties , hype etc around those games launches and non of that happened for this game

DireOwl

Yes IGN are the ones who lied. Although Sony is not an angel in this either. The purposely mislead people. They are well aware that the average person does not now the difference between sell-in and sell-through. They just wanted people to think "ZOMG Uncharted 3 sold 3.8 mil!? Peoples lov it!!!1! What am I mizzingz?! Imma go get it NAO!!!11!" or something to that meaning.

[QUOTE="ianuilliam"]

[QUOTE="ForzaGearsFace"] Gears probably at 5 million sell in 3 million sell thru uncharted 3.8 sell in 1. 1 sell thru you care to give me your guess lol I'd like to see u spin thisTheBigXboxski

[QUOTE="ianuilliam"]

[QUOTE="ForzaGearsFace"] Looks at cliffyb crying sig laughs and ok it didn't happen ForzaGearsFace

[QUOTE="ianuilliam"]

Lol. Did I say that? I don't remember... Link, or it didn't happen.

"If VGChartz is close to the mark on Gears, and this 3.8 million is actual day one sell in, Uncharted very possibly may have already passed Gears 3...That'd be pretty funny, since PS3 owners never buy any games..."

"I need to update my sig... I should totally make a "3.8 million in 1 day > 3 million in 7" banner... anyone know where I can find a pic of Cliffy B crying, or with his jaw dropped?"

"Someone should make a "Will Uncharted 3 outsell every 2011 360 exclusive combined?" thread."

marklarmer

i have to say i find you asking other people for evidence rather ironic, you've clearly mentioned both games sales multiple times and you obviously want Uncharted 3 to outsell Gears 3 :|

(I've now hit my self imposed limit of 1 response to ML/thread in this thread)

[QUOTE="ianuilliam"]

[QUOTE="ForzaGearsFace"] Ok so you are saying that gears was outsold by uncharted 3 day 1 though right?ForzaGearsFace

TheBigXboxski

Hey, weren't you the guy talking about how if you buy 100 cases of milk, and it sells, you buy more, but if you buy 100 cases, and it doesn't sell, you drop the price? So I guess Retailers sold their initial shipments of Gears (3 million in a week), so they reordered... but sales dropped down to a few hundred k by the second week, so they cut the price, barely 5 weeks after launch. Since everybody is saying there's no way that 3.8 million initial sell in will sell through, we ought to see Uncharted's price drop within 3-4 weeks, right? We should make a betting pool for how long till the price is cut.

[QUOTE="ianuilliam"]

[QUOTE="ForzaGearsFace"] Ok so you concede that gears sold more than un3? ForzaGearsFace

[QUOTE="ianuilliam"]

[QUOTE="ForzaGearsFace"]Ian wants us to believe uncharted 3 sold more than gears 3. Just agree because logic had failedForzaGearsFace

[QUOTE="ianuilliam"]

[QUOTE="ForzaGearsFace"]Ian wants us to believe uncharted 3 sold more than gears 3. Just agree because logic had failedForzaGearsFace