@Amity6 @l777l You have simply replaced "juvenile" with "immature" and "stupid". These are mere assertions. Please explain what's juvenile about it. Why is it juvenile/immature/stupid?
@AJMXYZ You are in that a Platonic relationship would have made sense as well. In a sense it still is one. John is rather reserved. And they painfully can't touch each other. Chief is a giant rock of armor, and Cortana does not exist in physical form.
I agree with you that this guy's critique is premature. And I even find that no deeper justification - an integral role - would be required.
l777l's comments